Duet WiFi firmware new feature priorities

jmg123

. J Dynamically-varying microstepping
2). D Support for PanelOne and similar 20x4 text displays, not including the SD card socket - see next item.
O. Support for restore points.
C. Predictive temperature control
S. MQTT client - so that actions could be performed by other things, e.g lights, alarms, home automation, during or on completion of the print. So as to make things a bit more secure, the duet wifi would only want to publish data, not subscribe to anything (with the possible exception of emergency stop) Shouldn't be too hard todo as there simple mqtt implementations based on LWIP floating around already.

Corexy

Just ordered mine right now…..so:

E. Support for an external SD card socket
A. Higher stepper motor current
C. Predictive temperature control
H. Grid-based bed compensation
J. Dynamically-varying microstepping

mhackney

Wow, that's a long and great list!

1 C Predictive temperature control
2 O Support for restore points
3 L Faster file upload speed
4 M Babystepping - if implanted with a usable UI
5 B Multi-threaded web server,

and some comments:

re: config_override.g - smoothieware uses this and it did nothing but drive me crazy! I frequently had unexpected results that turned out to be override settings. If you do go down this path, making it editable in DWC like the config.g is would go a long way to help.

SSH would be ideal over telnet but telnet is fine for me. I only run on my internal network so security is not a huge concern. But I can see it being important in an educational and industrial situation.

ROBUST DWC connections - I know huge progress has been made on this this year but it can still improve.

mhackney

Here's a new request: an option to perform both the auto calibration (G30 Sx) AND return the results the way S-1 does.

franknitty69

1 - predictive temp control
2 - grid based bed comp
3 - restore points
4 - dynamically varying microstepping
5 - Support for three independently-controlled Z motors

CodonExe

My vote is:

C. Predictive temperature control
J. Dynamically-varying microstepping
I. Faster microstepping
M. Babystepping
E. Support for an external SD card socket

deckingman

Just thought of a "anything else".

Some sort of running total of print time to date. A sort of "hour meter", or "mileometer". It would be useful for setting up maintenance schedules\reminders. Like "lubricate guides" every x number of hours or "change belts" every y hundred hours". I guess this is more a web interface thing, as it would need to be running total of when the printer is actually printing rather than power on time. Just a thought…....

bot

Oh yes, the hourmeter would be a very very nice feature. It could be nice to know individual axes' travel distances, as well as print hours, total powered up hours (for motors) etc.

RichRap3D

Very nice list, choices, choices…

My vote would be -

- F. Support for multiple independent X carriages.
- A. Higher stepper motor current (above 2A)
- P. Control over which access point
- N. Support for driving RC servos - But do the HW on the expansion header (shield) with a +5V reg + I/O etc.
- R. Support to compensate for axis hysteresis

In my first week of using DuetWifi I would have voted for E. Support for an external SD card socket, but now it's almost not even something I would think about, and it's annoying that other 3D printers are still using a slow external card…

Best Regards,

Rich.

Pumlux

I think this is my preference of order.

C. Predictive temperature control.
H. Grid-based bed compensation,
J. Dynamically-varying microstepping
O. Support for restore points.
G. Support for three independently-controlled Z motors

I read DC42 start post that way, the other topics will
not be dropped, just come later.

One suggestion from my side ( I believe the topic
was already discussed in some thread(s) on the RepRap forum)

What about having a dedicated button (pin) for pausing
the print (similar the pause Web Button) ?

Sometimes I have see someting strange during the print
and would like to pause. The Webbutton is to slow to reach
and a power off (like an emergency stop button)
ruins the print.

bot

The PanelDue offers exactly this pause button. I personally would never run a duet printer without a paneldue. It's a much more reliable and fast means of controlling the printer than the web interface. Keep in mind, the pause command does wait for the last gcode command to finish executing (or maybe even the whole queue).

BMMal

I just pre-ordered a board. One feature I want to request (if it doesn't exist already) is an extruder advance (aka JKN, Linear Advance, etc) to help compensate for hysteresis in bowden systems. My machine has some very long bowden tubes and enabling this (unfinished) feature in Marlin's RC Bug fix branch made a noticeable difference on corners and top infill quality.

dc42

@BMMal:

I just pre-ordered a board. One feature I want to request (if it doesn't exist already) is an extruder advance (aka JKN, Linear Advance, etc) to help compensate for hysteresis in bowden systems. My machine has some very long bowden tubes and enabling this (unfinished) feature in Marlin's RC Bug fix branch made a noticeable difference on corners and top infill quality.

Good news for you. RepRapFirmware has supported extruder pressure advance for around 18 months. See
http://reprap.org/wiki/Gcodes#M572:_Set_or_report_extruder_pressure_advance

BMMal

@dc42:

@BMMal:

I just pre-ordered a board. One feature I want to request (if it doesn't exist already) is an extruder advance (aka JKN, Linear Advance, etc) to help compensate for hysteresis in bowden systems. My machine has some very long bowden tubes and enabling this (unfinished) feature in Marlin's RC Bug fix branch made a noticeable difference on corners and top infill quality.

Good news for you. RepRapFirmware has supported extruder pressure advance for around 18 months. See
http://reprap.org/wiki/Gcodes#M572:_Set_or_report_extruder_pressure_advance

Excellent news! And it's per extruder, even better! Can't wait to get my hands on it!

PRZ

My own list for a printer:
1/ H grid-compensation
2/ C temp control with auto-tune
3/ D Simple panel
There was on forum someone asking for an odometer (recording filament consumption) and printing hour counter. That shall not be high priority, but that may be a nice to have.
The Duet WiFi having higher current capability, it can be possible to handle a CNC, but there is need to implement a few more G-Code

M0/M1 stop/start for tool change
M3/M5 start/stop spindle
M8/M9 Coolant on/off
M10/M11 : Vacuum (for part maintaining) - lower priority
Sn : spindle speed
Heaters output can be used to command SSR or to make a PWM for spindle speed control.
A 'standard' mapping shall be decided, e.g. E0 heater -> spindle on/off E1 heater -> coolant on/off , Bed heater -> Vacuum pump, Fan0 for spindle speed control.

Shapeoko is listing the G-code it is using here http://www.shapeoko.com/wiki/index.php/G-Code

Aussiephil

@PRZ:

There was on forum someone asking for an odometer (recording filament consumption) and printing hour counter. That shall not be high priority, but that may be a nice to have.

Hey that was me :), sort of forgotten about it but yes it would be good to have but low on the list

Second the CNC stuff….. that will be my next big project.

dc42

It's time to summarize which firmware features you want most. I allocated 5 points to your first choices, 4 points to your second choices usw. and added them up.

By far the most wanted feature is predictive temperature control with auto tuning (51 points). After that comes dynamic microstep generation (30), grid-based bed compensation (27), restore points (24), faster microstepping (23), and higher motor current (21) and babystepping (18).

I already implemented faster microstep generation and released it in firmware 1.14.

Dynamic microstepping and higher motor current are related, because they both involve the SPI interface ti the stepper drivers. So I plan to implement them together. This leads me to the following provisional plan:

#1 Predictive temperature control with auto calibration

#2 Higher motor current and dynamic microstepping

#3 Grid-based bed compensation

#4 Restore points

We also expect to have OEM customers for the Duet WiFi so I will be taking their views into account too.

bgkdavis

Really have to ask, but what on earth is 'predictive temperature control' are you talking about Feed forward or heuristic control?… both I would consider to be a poor replacement for PID.

The problem with PID control is tuning and most people who talk about tuning of PID rarely explain that the tuning methodology changes with the form of the PID algorithms (and there are many forms)

How about replacing the existing PID algorithm with an auto tune algorithm?

dc42

It's feedforward control. Why would you consider it to be a poor replacement for PID? PID is OK at correcting for small changes in the status quo, but it's fairly useless at achieving the target temperature in the first place.

bot

What exactly about it are you trying to improve? I don't think I've ever been unable to tune a PID adequately enough for it to have no ill-effect on prints.

One thing that would be nice for an alternate to PID, is for it to be able to set temperatures for times in the future. For example, have an idle heater heated up at the precise moment it is needed, rather than having to wait. It would account for the heatup (and cooldown) times and time the signals appropriately to have the heater ready or not when it is needed or not. This would be useful in the case of a stationary idle extruder.