Choosing ACT steppers



  • Hello,

    I'm currently working on a Delta printer design and would like to use 0.9° stepper motors for the axes. I've read some good comments about ACT motors in several comments, and I've found two motors that might be interesting - 17HM5424 and 17HM5417. I've found a list comparing the different stepper versions here:

    If I understand correctly, the 17HM5424 would be the better alternative because the lower inductance would allow for faster movement, is that correct?
    Also, is it worth using 0.9° steppers for the extruders (direct MK8-style) as well or should I use 1.8° steppers for that?

    Thanks
    Volker


  • administrators

    For the Duet WiFi, I would choose the 2.4A motor. For any other electronics including the Duet 0.8.5, I would choose the 1.7A one.

    I use geared extruders rather than direct drive because direct drive extruders often suffer from lack of torque. If you must use a direct drive extruder, then I think a 0.9deg/step motor would be a good idea in order to improve extruder resolution, as long as it has sufficient torque.



  • A bit late, but nevertheless: Thank you very much, David!
    I've assembled a preliminary version of one of my Delta towers, and it seems to work as intended.
    A follow-up question - how do I determine a sensible current setting for the steppers? https://duet3d.com/wiki/Choosing_stepper_motors reads "Plan to run each stepper motor at between 50% and 85% of its rated current." - does that refer to the 2.4A, and can I insert that value directly into the M906 line?


  • administrators

    Yes, if they are 2.4A motors then run them at between 50% and 85% of 2.4A. Currently the maximum supported on the Duet WiFi is 2.0A but that will be increased. The current in the M906 line must be given in mA.


Locked
 

Looks like your connection to Duet3D was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.