@dc42 Found the solution, I didn't realize this earlier but the Toolboard firmware I was using had actually been modified by a coworker. We bought a new toolboard and tried to connect CAN (thinking maybe an IC had been fried) and it worked, so we copied that firmware onto the toolboard I had been using and sure enough, works fine. So it was a software issue. Thanks for your help!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1bd3e/1bd3e3945f80da647cc4c99eb5f810d6dbe7499b" alt=""