Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

a UPS might be in order

Do you have a separated 5V rail (with its own PSU) just to power the Duet?

Nightowl

@infiniteloop Nope. It's just my 24V PSU

I wouldn't know how to do that, but it's only the Duet that's powered from the 24V, as the spindle has it's own power supply.

Still, the "ultimate" test failed at the same point, so I'm going to need to look at the 5V - or UPS - option!

But surely, if the power fails, it fails. What use is a 5V supply if it's on the same mains circuit?

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

Nope. It's just my 24V PSU

If you put your UPS on that, the Duet won't notice the loss of mains power: Without a voltage drop, M911 won't be executed … until the UPS runs out of juice. But then, you face the same situation as now.

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

What use is a 5V supply if it's on the same mains circuit?

You could either use a large capacitor, a tiny UPS or a power bank to keep the 5V alive for a while.

Nightowl

@infiniteloop
If you don't mind, is this something you would plug into the Duet's USB port, and would the power bank stay charged/charging whilst connected, then slowly (slower than the PSU) drain down giving more time to save what I need to save?

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

is this something you would plug into the Duet's USB port

Never. All the Duet boards I know of (don't know all of them) have an optional 5V input.

would the power bank stay charged/charging whilst connected

That depends on the power bank. Sorry, but due to my limited knowledge, I can't give you recommendations for specific devices. Have you searched the forum on this topic yet? I didn't, but I stumbled across some related posts in the past.

Nightowl

@infiniteloop OK, thank you. I'll ask this question separately then, burt I didn't want to seem impatient

Again, I really appreciate the time and effort you've put in to help me with this - you've been brilliant

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

I'll ask this question separately

Maybe you search before you ask? Chances are good that then, your questions are more specific. Fore example, I still face the miracle that my Duet doesn't execute the M911 command sequence if I shut off my large power supply but keep the 5V rail alive. Remember, I came across that when I ran some macro tests for this thread on my Duet.

So I'll dive into the ocean of Duet3D documentation and figure out how and when resurrect.g is triggered. This, in turn, seems to depend on how I configure and supply my various voltages.

What I mean is: if you ask how to connect a UPS (or a power bank), the replies don't include the aspect of recovery from power failure. Is the way we elaborated in this thread still viable, or do you then need a different solution? Or: depending on your power setup, you might be able to came along with a simple capacitor - which won't work well if all your steppers suck from that, too.

I suggest you go to the hardware section first (as a first read, I suggest this, this and something like this) and figure out how to separate the 5V from the rest. If you got the idea, ask the forum - not the other way round, because then, there's too much noise in the replies.

Nightowl

Thanks, @infiniteloop. I do try to search the forums and the documentation first, but I don't seem to find anything descriptive enough to work from so ask on the forum.

Of course, as I get to know stuff, I'll be asking fewer questions and giving more help

Thanks again, my friend

Nightowl

@infiniteloop
So maybe the issue may not be power decline related...

I changed a couple of things in the M911 line in the config.g file from:

M911 S23 R23.5 P"M98 P""SaveSpindleSpeed.g"" M913 X0 Y0 G91 M83 G1 Z3 E-5 F1000"

...to...

M911 S23 R23.5 P"M913 X0 Y0 G91""M98 P""SaveSpindleSpeed.g"

...effectively deleting the printer stuff and changing the file order, although I'm not sure if the latter made any difference. I also raised the threshold for power loss.

Now, the ResumeSpidleSpeed.g file is fully formed, which is great, but I'm getting a different error, twice, when I enter M916 in the MDI:

M292 Error: No P parameter and no active tool with spindle
M916 Error: No P parameter and no active tool with spindle

This clearly relates to the spindle - again - so I think the SaveSpindleSpeed.g file will need to edited to add those variables from the Object Browser.

I'm going to use your lead to see if I can finish this off....

infiniteloop

@nightowl999

I changed a couple of things in the M911 line

M911 S23 R23.5 P"M913 X0 Y0 G91""M98 P""SaveSpindleSpeed.g"

There's something wrong: the double quotation marks following G91 should not be there (and you can skip G91 completely), then, a second quotation mark to end the M98 argument is missing, finally, the closing quotation mark of M911 is missing, too. So try this instead:

M911 S23 R 23.5 P"M913 X0 Y0 M98 P""SaveSpindleSpeed.g"""

Let's try and see if the M292 and M916 errors persist.

Nightowl

@infiniteloo

Ooh, that's a lot of quotation marks...

I'll let you know how it goes...

Nightowl

@infiniteloop

That change truncated the writing of the RestoreSpindleSpeed. g

This is all I got...

; RestoreSpindleSpeed.g
; Spindle speed saved from running "0:/gcodes/Calibration Toolpath.gcode" CNC file

; set up the global variable abort_process so we can abort further execution of resurrect.g:
if {!exists(global.abort_process)}
    global abort_process = true
else
    set global.abort_process = true

Nightowl

@infiniteloop
I deleted the RestoreSpindleSpeed.g to see how much SaveSpindleSpeed.g would write, but there was nothing. Running the SaveSpindleSpeed.g file from the MDI produced the file, but obviously it didn't have any proer values

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

That change truncated the writing of the RestoreSpindleSpeed. g

That's what I expected. Due to the misplaced quotation marks, M911 didn't execute properly - I think that even resurrect.g has been malformed by that: this would explain the "No P parameter…" errors.

Sigh. One measure of last resort is to trim the execution time of SaveSpindleSpeed.g - with luck, we gain some nanoseconds. So make a copy of your actual SaveSpindleSpee.g file and put this into the macro, instead:

var fName = "RestoreSpindleSpeed.g"
echo >>{var.fName} "if {!exists(global.abort_process)}"
echo >>{var.fName} "    global abort_process = true"
echo >>{var.fName} "else"
echo >>{var.fName} "    set global.abort_process = true"
echo >>{var.fName} "M291 S3 R""Resurrect:"" P""Continue with <"^{job.file.fileName}^">?"""
echo >>{var.fName} "set global.abort_process = false"
echo >>{var.fName} "M3 S"^{spindles[0].active}

With luck, this will work, depending on the current load on the Duet. But I have to insist: that's not good practice, it's more like a ride on a razor blade.

Nightowl

@infiniteloop
Sorry, about this, but I tried something while you were cogitating...

I edited the M911 file to this:

M911 S23 R 23.5 P"M913 X0 Y0 M98 P"SaveSpindleSpeed.g"

...and it worked, apart from the spindle errors. The SavedSpindleSpeed was fully formed, too.

I don't think it's a timing thing afterall. The "processing" stays onscreen in the DWC for a few seconds, perhaps 2 or 3?

Nightowl

@infiniteloop

This is the file:

; RestoreSpindleSpeed.g
; Spindle speed saved from running "null" CNC file

; set up the global variable abort_process so we can abort further execution of resurrect.g:
if {!exists(global.abort_process)}
    global abort_process = true
else
    set global.abort_process = true

; now comes the dialog:
M291 S3 R"Resurrect:" P"Continue with <null>?"

; we will only arrive here if the dialog was closed with OK:
set global.abort_process = false
M3 S0

;EOF

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

I deleted the RestoreSpindleSpeed.g to see how much SaveSpindleSpeed.g would write, but there was nothing.

That's why I decidedly put the macro call at the beginning of the M911 sequence

Nightowl

@infiniteloop
OK, I'll change them back...

infiniteloop

@nightowl999 said in Power failure and resurrection on a CNC machine:

This is the file:

We are out of sync. delete that and look at the file resulting from the next power outage.