Question about fan control..

dc42 · 11 Dec 2017, 23:17

Which bit do you think is contradictory?

vbtalent · 12 Dec 2017, 02:30

The part about adding or removing the M106 command…

If using the Fan1/Fan0 is it needed in the config.g for them to be operational?

Without adding the M106 in the config.g file I can not get the part cooling fan working however the extruder fan does work without the M106.

deckingman · 12 Dec 2017, 08:07

Fans are optional so you need to add them to config.g if you want to use one. Having said that, the wiki extract you posted says this:

"We recommend you use the FAN1 connector for a thermostatically-controlled hot end fan, because on the Duet WiFi it defaults to being on at power up, to provide maximum safety if you restart your Duet when the hot end is hot."

Which is why your extruder fan works without putting a M106 P1 command in config.g. If you want to use a part cooling fan and if you connect it to the Fan0 connector, then you need to put an M106 P0 command in config.g.

dc42 · 12 Dec 2017, 09:36

The part cooling fan should work (i.e. respond to M106 commands generated by your slicer), at full speed at least, without any support in config.g if you have connected it to Fan 0. What might not work is turning it on at less than full speed, because you may have to reduce the PWM frequency or increase the blip time using a M106 command in config.g.

vbtalent · 12 Dec 2017, 12:05

For me the part fan on Fan0 does not come on unless I put in the M106 in the config.g however the extruder Fan1 is working as described.

In Slic3r there is a "Filament Setting" for "Cooling" which generates Gcode similar to the following

[c]…
M106 S219.3
M106 S140.25
...[/c]

if I use the following in my config.g file

[c]M106 P0 S1 I0 F500 H1 T45[/c]

I assume the Gcode lines from Slic3r will be interpreted and the Fan0 speed will be controlled as it prints and override the default settings in the config.g file?

Thanks for the input guys.

dc42 · 12 Dec 2017, 12:15

The S1 in your M106 command means turn on the fan at full speed. The H1 means control it thermostatically with the hot end temperature, which you probably don't want for the part fan, because it's normally best to print the first layer without the part fan running.

The M106 command in config.g should not be needed. Without it, the fan will be off until a M106 command generated by the slicer turns it on after the first layer, which is almost certainly the behaviour you need.

deckingman · 12 Dec 2017, 12:39

Whilst I think that the Wiki could be a little clearer in what needs to go in config.g and what doesn't, I can confirm that deleting M106 P0 from config.g has no effect on the print fan.

What may be confusing the OP however, is that in the web interface, the (print) fan is labelled "FAN1" not "FAN0" as might be expected.

dc42 · 12 Dec 2017, 13:02

@deckingman:

What may be confusing the OP however, is that in the web interface, the (print) fan is labelled "FAN1" not "FAN0" as might be expected.

Good point! I'll suggest to chrishamm that he changes it.

deckingman · 12 Dec 2017, 13:51

@dc42:

@deckingman:

What may be confusing the OP however, is that in the web interface, the (print) fan is labelled "FAN1" not "FAN0" as might be expected.

Good point! I'll suggest to chrishamm that he changes it.

While you are on, how about getting my pet hate fixed? That is extruder drives being labelled 1 to 5 instead of 0 to 4

i.e. assigning drives 0 to 4 to tools 0 to 4 but to check extrusion heat tool 2 but use drive 3. Grrrrrrr

dc42 · 12 Dec 2017, 15:31

@deckingman:

@dc42:

@deckingman:

What may be confusing the OP however, is that in the web interface, the (print) fan is labelled "FAN1" not "FAN0" as might be expected.

Good point! I'll suggest to chrishamm that he changes it.

While you are on, how about getting my pet hate fixed? That is extruder drives being labelled 1 to 5 instead of 0 to 4

i.e. assigning drives 0 to 4 to tools 0 to 4 but to check extrusion heat tool 2 but use drive 3. Grrrrrrr

Where are the extruder drives labelled 1 to 5?

deckingman · 12 Dec 2017, 16:16

@dc42:

Where are the extruder drives labelled 1 to 5?

DWC - Machine Control page - under "Extruder control" and just above "Miscellaneous" (which also shows "Fan1")

deckingman · 12 Dec 2017, 18:57

Also in print status under "Extrusion factors" they are labelled as Extruder 1, Extruder 2 etc. For the majority of people who only use a single extruder, they will only see one extruder (or drive depending on which page you are on) so it won't matter. It's only crazy people like me who have mixing hot ends that have the issue.

Cheers

vbtalent · 12 Dec 2017, 22:58

OK, great!

Thanks for the direction… Slicer controls fan in G-Code... M106 not required in config.g.

Sorry about the additional work, lol!

VB,