Kind help on req Duet3d hardware based on specification

coolice2020

@Veti

Understood! So, on one side, I check if they have any bipolar stepper motor, which still has these features.

On the other hand, could you recommend me please:

high-end stepper motor with similar feature set you can recommend ?

OR

high-end stepper motor and the add-ons required for Duet 3 to have these features within the Duet 3 board itself?

OR

a controller board can handle these drives ? (dont shoot me pls, I am in love with Duet 3 just trying to understand all options I have) ?

Many Many many thanks!

Veti

@coolice2020 said in Kind help on req Duet3d hardware based on specification:

high-end stepper

i dont understand what you mean by high end steppers.

there are high quality stepper motors
for example moons have got some good reviews
https://forum.prusaprinters.org/forum/original-prusa-i3-mk3s-mk3-user-mods-octoprint-enclosures-nozzles-.../stepper-motor-upgrades-to-eliminate-vfa-s-vertical-fine-artifacts/

Can you specify your requirements for the stepper. what holding torque do you need etc.

the duet 2 can handle external stepper drivers. or like i said you have to wait for the duet 3 to support them as well.

coolice2020

Based on Veti advise I finally decided on the E3D online stepper motors able to andled by the Duet 3 directly.
I will have 24V instead of 12V setup.
I will have a much moderate meanwell psu.
Replaced the BL touch with Duet IR probe for auto levelling.
Based on Tony advise, I am on research for the thermal fuse for the heated bed.
I will use Pi to take all networking processing stress away from Duet 3, (but keep using Web control), an dthe usb cam will attached to that too.
I reworked the water cooling for being push-pull with 4 large 800rpm fans, able to andled by the Duet 3 directly.

BIG thanks for all your patience and help, truly appreciated, keep you posted how the build went or in case I ran into any trouble/question !

coolice2020

Hi Again,

I am working hard to put together a final wiring diagram to be confirmed, but I ran into some questions, allow me kindly to ask them.

(I always try to search the forum and the docwiki before I ask, but if I am confused, better to be safe than sorry)

Background:

The Keenovo heatbed I had chosen has built in thermistor.
I had chosen a proper SSR.
I had found the wiring diagram for the Duet 3 6HC + SSR + Heatbed as well as the mainboard wiring digramm as well.

Question:

If I understood well, Duet 3 6HC use the thermistor value to know the actual temperature of the bed.
But do I need a separate thermostat attached to Duet 3 to control, or thats will be handled by Duet 3 natively, OR I need a TEMP DAUGHTERBOARD OR .. ?

Many thanks for your time and help!

Veti

most of the time the thermistors on those keenovo are B3950 Thermistor.
those can be connected directly to the duet3

coolice2020

@Veti said in Kind help on req Duet3d hardware based on specification:

B3950 Thermistor

As far as I see, it has: NTC 100K thermistor buil-in. This one works also ?

And back to my main question, no additional HRDW needed to control the temperature, so not only read it, but control it as well ?

Veti

@coolice2020

a B3950 Thermistor is a specific NTC 100K thermistor.

for ssr control please read
https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Choosing_a_bed_heater#Section_Bed_heater_driven_using_a_Solid_State_Relay

coolice2020

@Veti Big thanks, and I did read the SSR article you pointed to me already, I even have the SSR wiring diagram, so allow me to rephrase myself:

Having only a built-in thermistor and a properly applied SSR, is enough for Duet 3 to control on/of and specific celsius temperature, right ?

(So basically all not needed watts will be "burned" at SSR, simple is that if I understand well the concept behind)

Veti

@coolice2020

a ssr will turn the power on or off as needed. like a switch. if the switch is off no power flows.
the thermistor reads the temperature.

as long as the temperature is below the requests temperature the duet will let the power flow.
if its above the requested temperature , the power is turned off.

coolice2020

@Veti SUPER CLEAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I will add a fuse too, just as suggested in docwiki.

Big thank you !!!!!

(PS: i mark this for solved now, until i have new question. )

coolice2020

@Veti

May I ask an other quick question:

I am planning to use 2pcs (since dual head) of Duet3D magnetic filament monitor.

Questions:

Did I understood right, that this will work with ALL filament (even PVA or transparent) ?
Did I understood right, that BOTh can be attached directly to Duet 3 6HC without the need of any daughterboard or other extension ?
Do you truly recommend this? (I am asking this, as its very hard to buy, so would be great to know if this worth it or you recommend something else ?

Many many thanks for your time and help!!

Veti

@coolice2020

i dont use filament runout sensors. i prefer to use my eyes.

someone else might be able to comment.

coolice2020

@ Veti

Truly ? I see. In my case it can happen e.g. overnight, so I would love to make sure, that he printing paused, while I refill the filament.

Hoping may others can respond, especially on the technical prospective, whether the 2 filament sensor can be attached directly to the Duet 3 6hc, right ? I am asking this, because after reviewing this 2 docwiki source, it still not fully clear:

https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Connecting_and_configuring_filament-out_sensors

https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Duet3dFilamentMonitor_RotatingMagnetVersion

Veti

@coolice2020 said in Kind help on req Duet3d hardware based on specification:

Truly ? I see. In my case it can happen e.g. overnight, so I would love to make sure, that he printing paused, while I refill the filament.

the slicer will generate the amount of filament required in grams.
you can then weight the spool to see if there is enough filament on the spool before the print.

dc42

Yes you can attach several filament monitors to a 6HC. In RRF 3.2beta3, filament monitors attached to tool and expansion boards are supported too.

Please note, in all cases the filament monitor must be connected to the same board as the corresponding extruder drive motor. This is so that the firmware can correlate the commanded extrusion with the measured extrusion in real time.

coolice2020

@Veti

Fair point, however, when you dont want to have many spools with a small bit of filament left, without a sensor, you are unable to use a complete spool 100%, at least in my experience.

Veti

@coolice2020

i use the small leftovers, when i print smaller parts

coolice2020

@dc42

Thank you for the confirmation!!

i have 5 axis stepper motors (x,y, z1, z2, z3) and 2 extruder ones (titan aqua), so in total 7 stepper motors.

I am sure about the 5 to connect with 6hc directly to use the onboard stepper motor drivers, but the additional 2 titan extruder may fit as well without any expansion ?

And in case I cant get the Duet3D magnetic filament monitor as it seems out of stock everywhere, can you recommend any other you trust and can be well connected to 6hc ?

Many many thanks for your time and help!

coolice2020

@dc42 Not to hurry you, just to be able to step forward, may I ask your kind help on the 2 questions above? So:

if all 7 stepper motors (5 axis, 2 extruder) can be connected to 6HC directly ?
can you recommend any other reliable filament sensor works with 6hc direct (because duet3d cant be purchased anywhere)

BIG BIG thanks in advance, and sorry to take your time.

jay_s_uk

@coolice2020 the 6HC only supports 6 drives directly. To add any more you will have to use either a 3HC or toolboard via CAN