• Tags
  • Documentation
  • Order
  • Register
  • Login
Duet3D Logo Duet3D
  • Tags
  • Documentation
  • Order
  • Register
  • Login

Continuous vertical lines on shell

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved
Tuning and tweaking
8
44
4.8k
Loading More Posts
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • undefined
    nophead
    last edited by 16 Jul 2019, 10:44

    If you print something with different outside dimensions do you ever get diagonal lines? I can't see how the extruder can create vertically aligned striations.

    How many shells are you using. With single wall I sometimes see striations from the infill pattern through the wall.

    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
    • undefined
      mrehorstdmd
      last edited by 16 Jul 2019, 11:02

      I use F608 bearings for idlers in my corexy printer with the toothed side of the belts riding on them. I get no such vertical ridges. Maybe you need to use larger diameter pulleys. F608s are 22 mm in diameter.

      https://drmrehorst.blogspot.com/

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • undefined
        Diamondback
        last edited by 16 Jul 2019, 11:08

        @nophead said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:

        If you print something with different outside dimensions do you ever get diagonal lines? I can't see how the extruder can create vertically aligned striations.

        How many shells are you using. With single wall I sometimes see striations from the infill pattern through the wall.

        I'm usually using 3 shells at .4mm, the lines are always perfectly vertical, sometimes there are diagonal lines on top of that, not sure where those comes from.

        undefined 1 Reply Last reply 16 Jul 2019, 14:36 Reply Quote 0
        • undefined
          nophead @Diamondback
          last edited by 16 Jul 2019, 14:36

          @diamondback What happens on diagonal sides?

          If it was somehow a flow rate variability synchronised between layers I would expect it to look exactly the same.

          If it is due to variations in linear speed due to motors or belts I would expect the pitch to increase on a diagonal because each axis is moving slower for the same linear speed.

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • undefined
            Diamondback
            last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 00:43

            @nophead said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:

            @diamondback What happens on diagonal sides?

            If it was somehow a flow rate variability synchronised between layers I would expect it to look exactly the same.

            If it is due to variations in linear speed due to motors or belts I would expect the pitch to increase on a diagonal because each axis is moving slower for the same linear speed.

            Just tested, straight vs diagonal do differ quite a lot. I'm currently test printing something without micro step interpolation.

            undefined 1 Reply Last reply 17 Jul 2019, 11:42 Reply Quote 0
            • undefined
              petrzmax @Diamondback
              last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 11:42

              @diamondback Let us know about the results! 😉

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • undefined
                Diamondback
                last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 12:13

                Nope, no changes... Tried different micro stepping for both axis and the extruder, with and without interpolation, nothing...
                Is it possible that my motors are just crap? (or not well selected for the task at hand)
                I'm running these steppers on both axis and the E3D Pancake on the Titan.
                (Used to be one of the ACT ones as well but I significantly reduced the X carriage weight a while ago and switched to that small stepper then)

                ACT 17HS5425

                undefined 1 Reply Last reply 17 Jul 2019, 13:31 Reply Quote 0
                • undefined
                  deckingman @Diamondback
                  last edited by deckingman 17 Jul 2019, 13:31

                  @diamondback said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:

                  Is it possible that my motors are just crap?

                  Sort of, yes. How tight are your belts? The reason I ask is that as a general rule, stepper motor bearings aren't realy designed to take the high lateral loading that we tend to apply. There is a real temptation to apply the highest belt tension that we think we can get away with, or that the belt manufacturer recommends. However, with this sort of loading, it is eminently possible that some degree of "stiction" (for want of a better word) of the shaft can occur. It may not be much but it could be enough that the requirement for higher torque, coupled with the lower torque available for partial full steps (due to micro-stepping) might mean that the motor will have a tendency to jump to the nearest full step. i.e. small (say single digit) micro steps might not necessary translate into any physical movement of the motor.

                  This is more a theory on part than any sort of scientific fact. Although, when I first built my printer, I was a bit too enthusiastic with the belt tension and had to use very high motor currents to get any sort of reasonable speed.

                  But it would be easy enough to slacken the belt tension a bit just to see if makes any difference. Worth a try I'd have thought.

                  Ian
                  https://somei3deas.wordpress.com/
                  https://www.youtube.com/@deckingman

                  undefined undefined undefined 3 Replies Last reply 17 Jul 2019, 14:28 Reply Quote 0
                  • undefined
                    petrzmax @deckingman
                    last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 14:28

                    @deckingman So do You think that it's worth trying higher motor current? Which should fix this problem on slower moves?

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • undefined
                      Diamondback @deckingman
                      last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 15:26

                      @deckingman said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:

                      @diamondback said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:

                      Is it possible that my motors are just crap?

                      Sort of, yes. How tight are your belts? The reason I ask is that as a general rule, stepper motor bearings aren't realy designed to take the high lateral loading that we tend to apply. There is a real temptation to apply the highest belt tension that we think we can get away with, or that the belt manufacturer recommends. However, with this sort of loading, it is eminently possible that some degree of "stiction" (for want of a better word) of the shaft can occur. It may not be much but it could be enough that the requirement for higher torque, coupled with the lower torque available for partial full steps (due to micro-stepping) might mean that the motor will have a tendency to jump to the nearest full step. i.e. small (say single digit) micro steps might not necessary translate into any physical movement of the motor.

                      This is more a theory on part than any sort of scientific fact. Although, when I first built my printer, I was a bit too enthusiastic with the belt tension and had to use very high motor currents to get any sort of reasonable speed.

                      But it would be easy enough to slacken the belt tension a bit just to see if makes any difference. Worth a try I'd have thought.

                      Just tested this, I made the belts as loose as possible while still not skipping teeth and while that added a bunch of ringing as expected, it didn't really affect the lines...

                      @petrzmax said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:

                      @deckingman So do You think that it's worth trying higher motor current? Which should fix this problem on slower moves?

                      I actually had them fairly high (housing got a bit too toasty probably) I lowered it a bit yesterday so that the housing is only handwarm...

                      I think I'll try different printing speeds next...

                      undefined 1 Reply Last reply 17 Jul 2019, 15:57 Reply Quote 0
                      • undefined
                        deckingman @Diamondback
                        last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 15:57

                        @diamondback said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:
                        .......................

                        Just tested this, I made the belts as loose as possible while still not skipping teeth and while that added a bunch of ringing as expected, it didn't really affect the lines...

                        Oh well, it was worth a try..........(and bang goes that theory☺ ).

                        Ian
                        https://somei3deas.wordpress.com/
                        https://www.youtube.com/@deckingman

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • undefined
                          nophead @deckingman
                          last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 16:12

                          @deckingman said in Continuous vertical lines on shell:

                          coupled with the lower torque available for partial full steps (due to micro-stepping) might mean that the motor will have a tendency to jump to the nearest full step. i.e. small (say single digit) micro steps might not necessary translate into any physical movement of the motor.

                          This is a common fallacy / misconception that is all over the web. The torque available when microstepping is the same as full steps because the vector sum of the two coil currents is always the same. I.e. the peak current when only one coil is on is sqrt(2) times the current when both coils are on. So at any stop position the holding torque is the same. It isn't less at intermediate microstep positions.

                          It is true that the torque is always proportional to displacement from the rest position, so if you only move a very small step the torque applied is very low and may not overcome stiction. However that is only relevant at the start. If the the load does not move the displacement quickly increases and so does torque until it does move.

                          Once moving at constant speed the rotor lags the rest position by an amount that generates enough torque to overcome the dynamic friction. If that lag exceeds two full steps the motors stalls because the torque is sinusoidal so reaches a maximum. During acceleration it lags more and during deceleration it leads.

                          undefined 1 Reply Last reply 17 Jul 2019, 16:33 Reply Quote 2
                          • undefined
                            deckingman @nophead
                            last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 16:33

                            @nophead Thank you for the explanation - (actually I think I had read that before but had forgotten).

                            Ian
                            https://somei3deas.wordpress.com/
                            https://www.youtube.com/@deckingman

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • undefined
                              Diamondback
                              last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 17:25

                              New results: slowing things down significantly (ie just 25mm/s for the outer walls) seems to almost get rid of the problem, pitch of the lines seem unchanged but the amplitude is much smaller.
                              I'll try the other way and speed things up to see what happens

                              undefined 1 Reply Last reply 18 Jul 2019, 11:12 Reply Quote 0
                              • undefined
                                Phaedrux Moderator
                                last edited by 17 Jul 2019, 17:39

                                Do you think you could post a few photos of the printer, particularly the XY arrangement, and maybe a video of it in action? I'm a visual person, so it helps me to see what's going on in motion. Perhaps something will become apparent.

                                Z-Bot CoreXY Build | Thingiverse Profile

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • undefined
                                  petrzmax
                                  last edited by 18 Jul 2019, 10:49

                                  I was thinking if bad quality pulleys, for example misaligned center of the hole can create effect like this.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • undefined
                                    nophead @Diamondback
                                    last edited by 18 Jul 2019, 11:12

                                    @diamondback It would be interesting to see the stepper motor current waveform to see if there is some distortion at higher speed. Back EMF does normally have an effect but I am not familiar with these drivers as I haven't attached motors to my DUET yet.

                                    What supply voltage are you using?

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • undefined
                                      Edgars Batna
                                      last edited by Edgars Batna 21 Jul 2019, 10:23

                                      I had fought this problem on my CoreXY and in my case it was misaligned X Y linear rod bearings which created vibration (it's a custom contraption that I overtightened by mistake so it didn't run smooth). Plus, the motors were resonating and the vibration of the axis added to the resonance. I ended up going for 0.9deg motors and smoother rods and now it's 99% gone.

                                      On the topic of belt tension, I observed that no matter how tight you make them, the plastic parts on the axes (and possibly the belt) will give in until equilibrium is reached. Yeah, it might seem a bit tighter at first, but try checking again in a year.

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      36 out of 44
                                      • First post
                                        36/44
                                        Last post
                                      Unless otherwise noted, all forum content is licensed under CC-BY-SA