Simple switch Run-Out Sensor too sensitive. Add timeout?

FBG

@Phaedrux understood, tomorrow i will check

dc42

@FBG said in Simple switch Run-Out Sensor too sensitive. Add timeout?:

https://reprapworld.es/products/extruder/extruder_parts/filament_detection/filament_run_out_sensor_1_75mm/

Looks like the sensor is a spring-loaded switch. I can't see why such a sensor should be unreliable, as long as the filament path is sufficiently constrained. Maybe the switch mechanical sensitivity isn't properly adjusted? Can you provide a photo of the filament path where it passes the switch?

felek

@Phaedrux I get it, but I think a bit different.

Let's look an example:

printing some part
switch is depressed
printer is doing long travel > 2s (no extrusion)
in this time we check switch (interval 500ms/1s) and is depressed
so, we pause the printer

In scenario when we check extrusion length there is no problem, because while traveling we don't have extrusion.
That is my idea

T3P3Tony

@felek are you using a switch to detect filament presence/no presence or something more complicated for movement? because if just presence then there is no reason for the switch state to change if its extruding or not.

dc42

My guess is that the switch only triggers when the filament is under tension. But is that intentional in the design of the filament sensor, or due to poor manufacturing or poor adjustment?

felek

@T3P3Tony I'll try to explain my story.

I bought Dyze design sensor (https://dyzedesign.com/shop/filament-detector/sentinel/)
which looks pretty solid and it is simple on/off presence sensor.

I tested many materials from different suppliers, as you can image sometimes quality of filament is quite low (I mean filament diameter).

I had big trouble with this sensor, because it is optical sensor and sometimes when diameter is a bit smaller than reference sensor change the state. I checked it on oscilloscope.

In this case SimpleFilamentMonitor doesn't work well. So I decided to rewrite this code in order to set flag when filament is depressed. It is a simple filter which remove noises from sensor. I also added parameter to help adjust filter length (extrusion length).

I hope this image help to understand what I mean. It really helps when someone uses cheap filament sensor or low quality filament.

FBG

@felek @Phaedrux
Still i don't write ok the trigger2.g file...
If i write that wait and after check, check after some miliseconds but again start the file trigger2.g... Is a loop..
Could you give me the exact lines that you think that i must add...?

Phaedrux

@FBG What exactly do you have right now?

FBG

In config.g:
M950 J1 C"e0_stop" ; Filament RunOut Sensor E0
M581 T2 P1 S1 R1 ; Call trigger2.g

In trigger2.g
G4 S1 :Wait 1 second
And now...What?

FBG

If in trigger2.g i write:
G4 S1
M582 T2

Starting a loop....