What extruder motor and microstepping settings are you using? Have you checked that the extruder extrudes the correct amount? 837 steps/mm is about right for a 0.9deg motor using x16 microstepping. If your motor is 1.8deg then you need to halve the steps/mm.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1bd3e/1bd3e3945f80da647cc4c99eb5f810d6dbe7499b" alt=""