Duet3D PCB delta printer effector sneak preview
-
I'm fine with no piezos. And let me know if you need any prototypes on this side of the pond- there's a few PCB houses in california that have done PCB prototypes for me for very cheap.
-
Any chance you or T3P3 will make custom length Haydn Huntley magnetic arms and sell it all as a kit with the PCB?
-
I used the onboard nozzle contact sensor to do auto calibration and mesh bed levelling on my 300mm diameter bed delta today. After I remembered to remove the H corrections from bed.g and put in the new diagonal rod length, the deviation for both was around 20um. I'll do more tests tomorrow to check how reproducible the sensor is.
-
Any chance you or T3P3 will make custom length Haydn Huntley magnetic arms and sell it all as a kit with the PCB?
We will certainly explore collaborating with Haydn on purchasing his mag arms in larger volumes to bundle with the effectors, once we get closer to a production version. That makes sense for people in the UK/Europe at least (it makes less sense to import them from the US just to ship them back).
-
I'll keep my eye one this!
John
-
I'm curious about that custom e3d heatsink. Does it have the piezo disk integrated? I'd love an e3d hotend with simply three screws to mount it rather than the groove mount, but I'm not certain that I'd like to experiment with piezo disks. Can you clarify what that is in the photos?
-
I don't like the custom heatsink, not easy to leave a standard.
-
It's not a custom heatsink, it's a prototype of a new design that E3D is working on because a lot of people hate the groove mount.
-
-
@bot:
I'm curious about that custom e3d heatsink. Does it have the piezo disk integrated? I'd love an e3d hotend with simply three screws to mount it rather than the groove mount, but I'm not certain that I'd like to experiment with piezo disks. Can you clarify what that is in the photos?
No the E3D new heatsink prototype does not have a piezo disc or any other type of contact sensor integrated.
-
This is music to my ears! Thank you for collaborating with e3d on this.
-
Any chance you or T3P3 will make custom length Haydn Huntley magnetic arms and sell it all as a kit with the PCB?
We will certainly explore collaborating with Haydn on purchasing his mag arms in larger volumes to bundle with the effectors, once we get closer to a production version. That makes sense for people in the UK/Europe at least (it makes less sense to import them from the US just to ship them back).
I would buy it that's for sure - located in EU/SWE. I have a copy of David's delta and would love the same setup, incl
rails instead of wheels. -
I would buy it that's for sure - located in EU/SWE. I have a copy of David's delta and would love the same setup, incl
rails instead of wheels.I've just published the build details at https://miscsolutions.wordpress.com/2017/03/22/time-to-rebuild-my-large-kossel/. I haven't finished the commissioning instructions yet, and the section on the effector and hot end is a bit sketchy because we and E3D are making some design changes.
-
Nice blog post David! (I like the Escher lizards in the photos as well :P)
-
Hi, really cool development here. I'm just wondering, can the circuit board go at the heat break, so that the hot end and the cold end are on either sides of the circuit board? This would bring the nozzle closer to the effector plane and also help prevent the cold end cooling fan from cooling the hot end.
-
I looked at that, but there isn't enough room between the heatsink and the heater block to fit he PCB in without the heater block being very close to the PCB. However the next version will put the hot end about 10mm higher because there won't need to be a collar below the heatsink.
-
Another photo, this time with the wiring in place
The prototypes are working well. We're making a few design changes to further improve sensitivity and noise immunity, also E3D is changing the grooveless hot end mount. So some new PCBs are on order.
-
Really looking forward to a release! Love the idea to use a PCB directly as effector!
-
you know, for some reason i was thinking that you could put FSR with on the PCB. and if the PCB "flexes" it would be in its self the Z probe…
They make force devices like that, you could mound in between each 3 points in a direction going to the hotend.
Just some random thoughts
~Russ
-
David, this is awesome! Although I like my IR sensor, it has its limitations, and the contact solution like this would be great. However, I have a question. How this will accommodate existing mounting for arms? It does not look like the PCB has a lot of space to mount something like Rostock ball-cup attachments or u-joints, unless they are mounted on posts. The problem with switching arms is that it would also require switching (or adjusting) attachements on the carriage side, or possibly changing carriages. While this may be ideal for some people (as you have noted you have eliminated the tilt buy changing the arms/carriages), it does add to the total cost of the solution, as well as the time involved.
As for the weight of the PCB vs Al effector, I wouldn't think that a PCB is necessary lighter than Al plate such as http://713maker.com/effector.html or a similar from http://tricklaser.com. The 713 effector (without a mount) weighs in at about 10g and Rostock ball-cup plastic effector (without a mount) about 13g. Sure, there is an added weight of the mount, and PCB-only plate might be lighter, but I do not think it is really that important here, as the weight of E3D extruder is about 50-80g or even more for some models.
Regardless of the weights, I would propose separating the effector from the mount part. This way, people will be still able to use their current effectors/arms/carriages/rails without modification. I understand that it will require additional work for you, but it would save a lot of work and money for those who are not ready to buy the whole set. -Thanks.
