Heated Chamber PWM fan Help
-
@sonderzug , sorry, yes, I can control the heater element with PWM, but my fan motor didn't play nicely with PWM - it just stuttered or failed to run at all. I was generalizing a bit, but my particular fan motor is a single phase induction motor and it turns out that these need speed control with a variable frequency drive or a triac circuit like a dimmer switch. Other types of oven fan motors could be more straight forward. Like you, I have a thermistor in the build chamber. +1 for Paneldue support
-
@pawprinter have you tried playing with the PWM frequency with the F parameter? You might have luck getting it to spin with higher or lower than the default. Up to 30000hz can sometimes help.
-
@pawprinter I'm just noticing that I totally misread your post - I thought you were talking about the heater, which, of course, you can switch and control via Duet by SSR. But the fan is a whole different story. This is getting a bit OT; but if you're using the kind of oven fan I'm using, then its motor is AC and you can't just control that via PWM. You'll need a special controller that converts the Duet's PWM signal via phase angle control for example. I have a manual speed controller installed that I set to a fixed value (e.g. it's running all the time) and just control heater power.
-
Hi,
Since you were all talking about heated chambers, their fans and printing ULTEM,
Here is my setup for printing PPSU. (380-410°C)
I decided, instead of just piecing together pieces of an oven, to just build the printer into the oven.
I am also waiting for the integration of the heated chamber into the PanelDue, as well as a vertical orientation option for the PanelDue.
If there is interest, i will start a build log.Cheers
Max -
@Phaedrux Thanks, I didn't think about changing the frequency. I'll give it a go.
@sonderzug no problem. You rather confirm what I thought about ac motors, so yes, probably OT unless the above does work
@NitroFreak excellent idea! -
@mrehorstdmd Interesting post. I have a similar printer that has a setup like this from the factory. It's a creatbot D600 Pro.
I am finding that the blower fan is far too powerful on bang-bang mode and it causes banding in my prints. When I PID tune the chamber heater (which triggers the blower fan just like your setup) it works really well and the temp is super stable and prints look great.
This however causes the lights throughout my entire home to "pulse" or "flicker", I wouldn't consider it a dimming. Have you seen this behavior at all with your setup or are you getting by with bang-bang mode fine?
I've seen this reported quite commonly with beer brewing kits that use heating elements with PID control and cause lights to flicker, but I'm still uncertain what the fix is.
-
@sonderzug How stable is the chamber temp in your machine like this, how much does the temp fluctuate in there?
-
@darkstarone experiment with the PID frequency of the heater. I had to reduce the frequency of my bed heater to 10hz to stop my pot lights from flickering.
-
@phaedrux I did try this on a very wide range and unfortunately none of them seemed to help. I've actually just disconnected the blower fan from the SSR and wired it up as "Fan 2" on the duet and leaving it set to about 10% all the time, and put the heating element on bang-bang, will see how this works out.
-
@darkstarone said in Heated Chamber PWM fan Help:
@mrehorstdmd Interesting post. I have a similar printer that has a setup like this from the factory. It's a creatbot D600 Pro.
I am finding that the blower fan is far too powerful on bang-bang mode and it causes banding in my prints. When I PID tune the chamber heater (which triggers the blower fan just like your setup) it works really well and the temp is super stable and prints look great.
This however causes the lights throughout my entire home to "pulse" or "flicker", I wouldn't consider it a dimming. Have you seen this behavior at all with your setup or are you getting by with bang-bang mode fine?
I've seen this reported quite commonly with beer brewing kits that use heating elements with PID control and cause lights to flicker, but I'm still uncertain what the fix is.
It looks like I actually have the chamber heater running in bang-bang mode. I haven't seen any lights flickering, but it's only a 500W heater. I haven't seen any problems with prints because the heater and fan are located about 700 mm below the XY stage. Even if the air is moving at the bottom of the printer, there's not much movement at the top. When the bed is all the way at the bottom of the Z axis, the fan is below the bed surface, so it won't be blowing air directly on the print, though it may tend to cool the bed plate a bit. I haven't printed anything that tall in quite a while. The fan I used isn't a particularly high flow type.
-
@darkstarone said in Heated Chamber PWM fan Help:
@phaedrux I did try this on a very wide range and unfortunately none of them seemed to help. I've actually just disconnected the blower fan from the SSR and wired it up as "Fan 2" on the duet and leaving it set to about 10% all the time, and put the heating element on bang-bang, will see how this works out.
So is it the blower, or the heater that's causing it? You can adjust the PWM frequency for both. That must be one intense blower in that thing.
-
It will be the heater. Turning a high powered heater on increases the load on the electricity supply, which will cause a drop in supply voltage due to the resistance of the supply wires. It's likely to be worse using 110V mains than 230V, because the current is double (unless the heater is wired between the two phases, so that it gets 220V) and your lighting is twice as sensitive to voltage drop. Even so, with the 240V mains here, whenever we turn the microwave oven on the lights dim momentarily.
Some types of lighting are more sensitive to mains voltage than others. I would expect non-dimmable LED lamps to be less sensitive than most other types of lamp, but I haven't done any tests.
There are two ways of controlling power to AC heaters: the phase shift methods, and the burst-fire method. Phase shift is what light dimmers do, on each half cycle of mains they pass only part of that half cycle to the load. But phase shift devices distort the electricity waveform, so the power companies don't approve it it being used for controlling heavy loads.
Burst fire means that complete half-cycles are passed to the load, or not. It's kinder to the electricity generator, but likely to cause flickering of associated lighting.
When you use a zero-crossing DC-AC SSR to control a heater, you get burst fire control. If you want phase shift control instead, see this thread https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/9397/ssr-with-analog-input/2. The Crydom MCPC analog SSRs are phase shift controllers.
Duet WiFi hardware designer and firmware engineer
Please do not ask me for Duet support via PM or email, use the forum
http://www.escher3d.com, https://miscsolutions.wordpress.com -
@mrehorstdmd Thanks for the confirmation. I have a feeling the banding is maybe caused by the blower being too powerful and blasting hot air all over the print, really fast. So I'm going to experiment with leaving the fan under the duet's control separately and leave it on a really low speed so it's a gentle breeze. Maybe the temp swing won't be enough to play with the prints.
I've observed this on both ABS and ASA filaments.
-
@dc42 Thanks for the information. Even though the heating element is on a different circuit, it seems that it can still have an effect due to the shared neutral.
-
@darkstarone It doesn't fluctuate at all, the temps are perfectly stable (unless I open the door of course). It's a very sluggish system with a lot of heat capacity, so you don't notice the heater coming on at all.
I do notice the same effect with the oven light that's installed in the build chamber (which acts as its own 25W heater btw), which flickers when the duet kicks on the heater element. It's a visible flicker because I'm running the heater with 10 Hz PWM (SSR-compatible).
