Help to setup BMG clone extruder
-
@zapta said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
Does the Duet license forbids commercial cloning? If not, they must have their reasoning for allowing it.
No. See: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/T3P3/Duet/master/LICENSE
-
@grizewald said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
No. See: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/T3P3/Duet/master/LICENSE
Some developers choose to allow commercial competition (e.g. Arduino, Duet), some not, and some even include license hardware in their product (e.g. Teensy). Each and their goals and considerations. Would be interesting to hear Duet's explanation why they chose to allow.
-
@zapta If you watch Tom Sanladerer's video from today, he asked exactly that question.
-
@DocTrucker said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
However in terms of the effect of clones on the original company what is the difference between me buying second hand rather than new compared to me buying a clone? For instance in the cold light of day I would have to say the logical conclusion is likely to be I am causing just as much damage to Duet3D buying second hand and asking questions on here as I would be if I had bought a clone.
Absolutely NOT damaging to purchase second hand. In fact, it HELPS the original company establish value, and brand equity. It helps quite a bit. It's called a "Healthy secondary market". Knowing that a given product can be re-sold for more than a pittance, that knowledge helps original purchasers make the decision to buy that product up front.
Contrast that to a clone. No benefit to the original, and a high potential to damage brand equity, because of poor clone quality.
I could expand on both statements above quite a bit... I think people get the point, so I'll keep it short.
-
@Danal appreciate the different view point. I was considering it from a purely revenue point of view.
Edit: That makes sense to me, and I can see why second hand is better than clone for companies like Duet3D that have embraced Open Source. With terms like 'planned obsolescence' kicking around it is not always embraced by all industries, some of which purely see coin as king and look little further in directing their business. The latter likely to be a failing of shareholders who only care for their dividend.
-
@zapta said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
Would be interesting to hear Duet's explanation why they chose to allow.
As I mentioned before I imagine they are able to punch above their weight due to the the community pitching in on support. But there is more to it.
The more restrictions put on something the more you come across as self centred and closed. RADDS being an example of something that should have really killed off RAMPS but the fuss around the open source but not open source left it struggling for a market corner. It's there, but not as much as it should have been. ...or is my exposure to Duets clouding my judgement a little and far more RADDS boards were shipped than Duet v0.6/v0.8.5?
Allowing others the right to manufacture also removes a little of the worry about 'what if company x goes bang' for companies who rely on the Duet hardware in their business. License restrictions don't always die with the company. So for bigger (edit: read as customer) companies it allows a little more room for letting the guard down a little and not spending too much resource maintaining familiarity with a secondary architecture.
-
Three on the bounce, sorry! Final point on this one before I drop back to my code and Primordial Radio podcast....
Another factor about this is trust and honestly. If you completely open source the product and don't limit the manufacture then you are leaving your self open to being undercut. Due to that you aren't likely to mark up your products as heavily as a closed company. You are outwardly stating you don't think you are unduly profiteering from your product. I'd say this is borne out by the difference in price of genuine to clone duets. Yes it is a significant value, but not something like a quarter of the original price despite being manufactured in a far cheaper location with little development costs, no support, and little government and environmental oversight.
The margins on Bondtech are more stark, but as I illuded to before the cloners have cut cost by tooling up for injection molding. This was a gamble by them, as there is a significant investment in at least time to get a tool running well before you can make your £0.40 copies. It also means they are not as free to innovate (fat chance, more like cut more cost) or adapt. It wouldn't surprise me if a ready to run tool would cost a UK company £10-20k. The cloners will also be tolerating a larger deviance from spec than Bondtech, and additionally may have made other sacrifices in either material quality (maybe even legality) and design for manufacture to reduce costs. In addition they can't innovate as quick as the original developers.
Because Bondtech (I'm assuming these are open source and not being illegally copied?) and Duet3D are Open Source and planned for such the cloners are likely to need to cut corners in order to offer any reduction in price. For both that maybe being a few revisions behind current and for Duet that may include hidden corner cuts like the thickness of copper tracks.
As others have said it would be unfair to evaluate a Bondtech with a clone. The titans are cloned too. I had a job lot of genuine E3D stuff from a seller on ebay (who was moving out of the business) and that included a clone titan (which wasn't complete - so I ironically bought the spares from E3D meaning they profited from a clone!) that I tried using on one of my Ormerods and it proved both worse than the RepRapPro style extruder and the genuine article years ago. Likewise the clone Bondtech I have isn't on parr with the genuine article that I have also used.
I do look forward to casting out the two clones I have - the clone titan is not in use! The only way I could have bought Bondtechs right now would have been on Finance. Yes I could have afforded the cost but that money would be better spent on filament and tolerating a RepRap extruder for a bit longer. Current price for a Bondtech (yeah, I've been spelling it wrong!) is £76.51 after conversion to Sterling from Euro. Bank of England base rate on interest is 0.75%, lets say 5% for the sake of argument. So I have cost a bank or lender in the order of £12 in lost interest over the maximum of 3 years that I intend to use them. However, had the clone option not have been there I would have gone RepRap and so it is a fake lost profit if that makes any sense?
Running 3 P3Steel with Duet 2. Duet 3 on the shelf looking for a suitable machine. One first generation Duet in a Logo/Turtle style robot!
-
@TPJensen How are you fairing so far?
Esteps on the extruder is a hardware value. It is best set it to your machine EXACTLY, not what is published.
Use your best toleranced filament and compute it. The longer the sample that you use for calibration the better it will average out any error.
I use the cold extrude gcode, remove the bowden tube from the hotend, cut the filament flush to the tube, extrude a meter, 1000mm and measure with a metric tape measure from the end to the bowden tube face. Even with inaccuracy of a tape measure, it comes out pretty good. At 1000mm, the error of what you might make reading a 100mm sample is going to average down to 1/10 of that.
The difference you might see when you are printing is going to be from differences in filament diameter and 'die swell' for lack of a better term. some filaments swell when they are heated and extruded, an ti can change at different temps too.
Depending on your slicer, there are ways to tweak it in the slicer profile. If you have an extrusion factor for example. In Slic3r PE, for some PLA I have it as low as 0.93 or even 0.88 for some really fussy stuff.
You can use the extrusion multiplier on the PanelDue or DWC, but the risk there is you forget that you fussed with it there and if you dont clear it, the next print when you change filaments could get messed up. I just use that adjustment to figure out the extrusion factor to put back into the slicer.
sinneD
ps: I have both original Bondtech and clone BMG's and QR's. Its a night and day difference in the real deal. At least buy the real gears from Martin. You wont be sorry.
-
@deckingman said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
@DocTrucker Each individual has their own opinion of what is right and what is wrong and it's not my place to make moral judgments. But at the same time, I have my own set of values by which I run my own life. For that reason, if a person buys a clone then I personally will not offer to help them, because to do so would be helping the vendor or maker of the clone, which is against my own personal principles.
Nothing personal and I respect your choice, but im afraid it is a total oxymoron.
On the one hand you say
"it's not my place to make moral judgments"
Then on the other you say
"I have my own set of values by which I run my own life. For that reason, if a person buys a clone then I personally will not offer to help them"
That by its very definition is a moral judgement................
-
I Have relayed before I purchased a cloned Duet 2 Wifi, from Fsytech I think, purely for comparison purposes, it is not used in a live machine, it's still in a box unused to this day
I also offered to donate this clone to the Duet team if they wanted to dissect it, but they either missed the post where I made the offer or they chose to not take up the offer.
I have a total of 18 genuine Duet-2 boards (7 in home machines & 11 at work) plus 1 Duet-3 so im quite comfortable that I have done my part in supporting Duet3D.
From looking at the two boards, the clone beside a genuine under a stereo scope there is a few subtle differences, enough differences to see that corners have been cut and its a good idea to stick with a genuine board.
A pic of the clone beside a genuine board (and the offer for me to ship it to Duet3D still stands if they want the board for comparison purposes)
-
@DocTrucker said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
The margins on Bondtech are more stark,
Maybe, maybe not. The cost of doing business in Sweden is horrible, particularly if you are a small company. Many years ago, I looked at starting my own business here and worked out that for every 10 pounds in my pocket, I would have to charge my customer 40 pounds.
That simply wouldn't fly, so I have remained a wage slave instead.Because Bondtech (I'm assuming these are open source and not being illegally copied?)
Bondtech's designs are not open source.
-
@grizewald now your last comment muddies the water significantly!
I did an install for a Laser Melting layer manufacturing machine in Switzerland many years ago. Think it was Zhaw or something like that. Nice place but as you say cost of living is crazy. Pizza and a beer out cost me more than a decent restaurant meal bak in the uk.
Running 3 P3Steel with Duet 2. Duet 3 on the shelf looking for a suitable machine. One first generation Duet in a Logo/Turtle style robot!
-
@deckingman said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
Each individual has their own opinion of what is right and what is wrong and it's not my place to make moral judgements.
We live in very judgmental times. The Puritans are back but with different religions, and the virtue signaling race pushes people to the extremes.
It's refreshing to see the tolerance, respect of different views, and commonsense in this small community.
-
@DocTrucker said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
@grizewald now your last comment muddies the water significantly!
I did an install for a Laser Melting layer manufacturing machine in Switzerland many years ago. Think it was Zhaw or something like that. Nice place but as you say cost of living is crazy. Pizza and a beer out cost me more than a decent restaurant meal bak in the uk.
Sweden and Switzerland are two very different countries!
-
@grizewald indeed. Scan read fail.
-
@sinned6915 said in Help to setup BMG clone extruder:
@TPJensen How are you fairing so far?
It is up and working now and makes good prints... my Esteps was 368.21 that looks spot on in the prints. Some filament as you say is a bit differnt in my simplify3d. 0,99 - 0,95
I love the Duet2 wifi board and paneldue in my mind the best upgrade I have. On PanelDue there is only one thing and that is baby steps can only be done when the printer starts. I know I can do it on webcontrol just it could be nice to have the option.
-
I bought the gears and Printed my own,which I felt was more in the open source spirit.
