Well I solved this because I didn't understand RRF. (I've literally been at this for nearly a week)
I was looking under "Machine Properties" and was going by that. I expected the signaling to change there but that is not the case.
I had to just send M591 D0 to get what the ACTUAL status of the filament sensor was.
With P1, it was wrong. With P2, it inverted it and triggered when filament was not present.
Hopefully this helps another noob like me out.