Duet3D Logo Duet3D
    • Tags
    • Documentation
    • Order
    • Register
    • Login

    Watercooled Smart Effector In Larger Effector || 4th Axis Design

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved
    Smart effector for delta printers
    smart effector mounting effector water cooling 4th axis delta additional axis
    11
    43
    4.0k
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Nxt-1undefined
      Nxt-1 @Dougal1957
      last edited by

      @dougal1957 said in Mounting a smart effector in larger effector - watercooled:

      Sorry to put a dampener on your work but I don't think it will work, With the feed tube/blocks where they are I don't think you will have anywhere near enough clearance for the arms so your print radius is going to be severely limited and should you go beyond that limit you are likely to get an arm disconnection. I hope I am wrong but I would attempt to mount it and see before you go much farther. Also you might like to Check out the Zesty Kryo

      No worries about damping 🙂 , I have been thinking the same about clearance. In the current design, I have placed the ball joint connections at close to the edge of the smart effector pcb as I physically possible. If clearance issues arise, I can move them outwards or increase the spacing between the rods.

      On terms of the Zesty Kryo, holy crap. That seems just about what I was looking for. I have to interest into getting the rest of the Nimble ecosystem but I will definitely look at the Kryo. One issue, did Zesty discontinue the Kryo. I cannot find a source for it.

      Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
      Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

      Nxt-1undefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • oliofundefined
        oliof
        last edited by

        Also, check out https://hackaday.io/project/158650-folds-and-hinges-technology-to-make-mechanisms/log/147838-ultra-light-extrusion-toward-the-graal for a very interesting and simple water cooling design.

        <>RatRig V-Minion Fly Super5Pro RRF<> V-Core 3.1 IDEX k*****r <> RatRig V-Minion SKR 2 Marlin<>

        Nxt-1undefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • Nxt-1undefined
          Nxt-1 @oliof
          last edited by

          @oliof said in Mounting a smart effector in larger effector - watercooled:

          Also, check out https://hackaday.io/project/158650-folds-and-hinges-technology-to-make-mechanisms/log/147838-ultra-light-extrusion-toward-the-graal for a very interesting and simple water cooling design.

          I saw that design when they released it but I do not think it is direct compatible with the E3D ecosystem that I use. Futhermore, it does not seem to be a likely fit for a smart effector.

          Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
          Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

          oliofundefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • oliofundefined
            oliof @Nxt-1
            last edited by

            @nxt-1 agreed on the extruder and it definitely is not a simple E3D drop-in. That said, the hotend/cooling part might fit. I heard mixed opinions on the ceramic heater with the thermistor in the nozzle though ...

            <>RatRig V-Minion Fly Super5Pro RRF<> V-Core 3.1 IDEX k*****r <> RatRig V-Minion SKR 2 Marlin<>

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • Twigzundefined
              Twigz @Nxt-1
              last edited by

              This post is deleted!
              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • Nxt-1undefined
                Nxt-1 @Nxt-1
                last edited by

                @nxt-1 said in Mounting a smart effector in larger effector - watercooled:

                @dougal1957 said in Mounting a smart effector in larger effector - watercooled:

                Sorry to put a dampener on your work but I don't think it will work, With the feed tube/blocks where they are I don't think you will have anywhere near enough clearance for the arms so your print radius is going to be severely limited and should you go beyond that limit you are likely to get an arm disconnection. I hope I am wrong but I would attempt to mount it and see before you go much farther. Also you might like to Check out the Zesty Kryo

                No worries about damping 🙂 , I have been thinking the same about clearance. In the current design, I have placed the ball joint connections at close to the edge of the smart effector pcb as I physically possible. If clearance issues arise, I can move them outwards or increase the spacing between the rods.

                On terms of the Zesty Kryo, holy crap. That seems just about what I was looking for. I have to interest into getting the rest of the Nimble ecosystem but I will definitely look at the Kryo. One issue, did Zesty discontinue the Kryo. I cannot find a source for it.

                Comming back to the Kryo, I just heard back from Zesty directly and it seems that some users reported leakages appearing after a while. The guys over at Zesty make the right call and pulled the Kryo from sales until they can release a re-engineered version.

                Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • Nxt-1undefined
                  Nxt-1
                  last edited by

                  I've been continuing the work on this project. I've had a few failed print due to clogging, I assume from the heatbreak overheating. The last couple of print are doing fine however. I measured some temps with a thermocouple and the water rises to 30-35°C and the copper waterblocks themselves to around 44°C.
                  2019-10-19 11.09.36.jpg 2019-10-19 11.09.43.jpg

                  Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                  Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • Nxt-1undefined
                    Nxt-1
                    last edited by

                    There is also a thread concerning monitoring the water temps with a 10K thermistor here.
                    And a thread about getting the part fan to work here.

                    I have also decided to go full blow and mount some radiators on the 4th axis arm. Furthermore, I ordered an off-the-shelf water cooled heatsink from Germany. I plan to turn down the groovemount down to 12mm on a lathe and thread it to M12 myself. Not only is probably a better solution cooling wise but also way less tubes down at the effector. I feel the short tube in tight corners are in a way constraining the Z-probe action of a smart effector.

                    Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                    Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                    • Nxt-1undefined
                      Nxt-1
                      last edited by

                      As described in a separate thread I now use a different way of mounting (the new) water cooled heatsink. This makes tubing a lot neater and should give better performance. I will keep this thread updated with the results once I find the time to properly do some testing.

                      Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                      Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                      Nxt-1undefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • Nxt-1undefined
                        Nxt-1 @Nxt-1
                        last edited by

                        @Nxt-1 Here is a quick status update. I am currently figuring out how I am going to implement the counterweight for the 2-2.5kg that the 4th axis weighs. The current plan is to cut a stack of disk out of lead sheet, so I can stack more weights as needed.
                        2019-11-17 10.40.09.jpg 2019-11-17 10.40.01.jpg

                        Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                        Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • fmaundefined
                          fma
                          last edited by

                          I'm using a FNU (http://reprapuniverse.com/catalog/store.php?cPath=44_155_157), and made a water-cooled block with a simple piece of aluminium (25x25x10), and a few holes:

                          FNU_watercooled.png

                          It works fine. It does not require much water flow; my previous pump died, and I'm about to buy a peristaltic one.

                          I also made a version for a E3D-v6, for friends:

                          E3D-v6_watercooled.png

                          but for now, nobody tried it... It requires a new thermal heat-break, which can be found on ebay (M6 thread on full-length)

                          Frédéric

                          Nxt-1undefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • Nxt-1undefined
                            Nxt-1 @fma
                            last edited by

                            @fma I never heard of the FNU style nozzle/hotends, looks interesting. As for your waterblock, looks nice, clean and effective. I assume there are four fittings to avoid needing a channel machined in there and simplify the manufacturing process?

                            Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                            Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • fmaundefined
                              fma
                              last edited by

                              @Nxt-1 said in Mounting a smart effector in larger effector - watercooled:

                              @fma I never heard of the FNU style nozzle/hotends, looks interesting.

                              Note that I broke one while doing 5 axis printing (forgot to lift up Z at the end of the print, and it collided with the part ☹). On the second one, I cut the tip of the nozzle, and only let the threaded part. This way, I can use any nozzle I want (like the Zatsit one, I'm still waiting for).

                              As for your waterblock, looks nice, clean and effective. I assume there are four fittings to avoid needing a channel machined in there and simplify the manufacturing process?

                              Exactly: just through all holes! I put a shunt tube on one side, so I only need 2 tubes for the water supply.

                              Frédéric

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • fmaundefined
                                fma
                                last edited by

                                FNU are availabe here:

                                http://reprapuniverse.com/catalog/store.php?cPath=44_155_157

                                Frédéric

                                tech-ratonundefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • tech-ratonundefined
                                  tech-raton @fma
                                  last edited by tech-raton

                                  @fma same idea here. A smaller block is easier...
                                  Delta
                                  alt text

                                  Core xy
                                  alt text

                                  For the delta, 2 holes drilled to M5. A M7 hole for the heatbreak.

                                  For the core xy, 3 M5 holes and a M7 for the heatbreak.

                                  I put a thermistor on the heatsink. The temperature rises to 29 degrees max in a heated enclosure at 40.

                                  Nxt-1undefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • Nxt-1undefined
                                    Nxt-1 @tech-raton
                                    last edited by

                                    @tech-raton Looks good! How confident are you using those push fittings in a moving setup? I have seen their internal teeth do a number on the ptfe filament tubes after a while. Never to the point of actually cutting it, but still.

                                    Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                                    Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                                    tech-ratonundefined 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • tech-ratonundefined
                                      tech-raton @Nxt-1
                                      last edited by tech-raton

                                      @Nxt-1 they come from my company. They are used in robotic application. They are good enough for me, for now...

                                      The bowden tube inside another tube (in the delta) will break before the pushfit.

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • fmaundefined
                                        fma
                                        last edited by

                                        I use Festo pushfits: no leak so far (my hotend is now working for more than a year).

                                        Frédéric

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • Nxt-1undefined
                                          Nxt-1
                                          last edited by

                                          I'm going to start digging already, I should have this thread dug out by the time I am ready to post the latest update in this project 🙂

                                          Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                                          Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • Nxt-1undefined
                                            Nxt-1
                                            last edited by

                                            Enough digging up old threads for while, let's get to the update 🙂

                                            From my last update post in this thread the design had already changed a little. Nothing in terms of function but mainly changing the way the radiators are mounted. The old way put a rather large moment arm on the carriage due to the large-ish overhang and their high weight. Below are two pictures illustrating the current situation.

                                            From the top view one can see that the extruder is located on the Z axis centerline (0,0,Z). Assuming the effector could tilt fully horizontal and the bowden could exit the hotend at a 90° angle as well, the bowden length would need to be BedDiameter / 2. In practice the extruder mount can rotate around the Z axis 360° (within reason, as the bowden and electronics cannot keep turning in the same direction) and about 85° tilt from the Z axis. So the bowden will need to a tad longer to account of that and the bend radius at the hotend.

                                            While this setup has worked quite well for me for about half a year, updates and improvements are always around the corner 🙂

                                            2020-03-17 15.39.11.jpg

                                            2020-03-17 15.39.03.jpg

                                            Duet3D and delta printer enthousiast. Buildlog
                                            Looking for Duet3D configuration support, check out Nxt-3D

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                            • First post
                                              Last post
                                            Unless otherwise noted, all forum content is licensed under CC-BY-SA