Spirograph emulator with Duet2

mrehorstdmd

@o_lampe Thanks. All the files are tested, so not an issue. I'll be able to access the machine this afternoon and will try out the random selection. I'm not too sure about the syntax. I've been testing the syntax via the console on my 3D printer and it doesn't look promising. If I enter M98 p"{random(55)}^.gcode" it returns {random(55)}^.gcode not found. It isn't converting the expression to a random number, or even treating it as an expression, just a string of characters. I've tried a few variations on the syntax and none have worked so far.

When I run echo random(416) on the console, it returns a random number (sometimes 3 digits), so I know random is working the way it should. Maybe I need to set a variable to a random value, and use that variable in the M98 command.

Renaming the files is pretty easy- I used Bulk Rename Utility. It takes just a couple seconds to set it up.

ironhydroxide

@mrehorstdmd said in Spirograph emulator with Duet2:

If I enter M98 p"{random(55)}^.gcode" it returns {random(55)}^.gcode not found. It isn't converting the expression to a random number, or even treating it as an expression, just a string of characters. I've tried a few variations on the syntax and none have worked so far.

you need to complete the quotation, then append the value, then continue the quotation.

~~M98 P""" <-gives you M98 "~~
~~^{random(55)} appends the result of the random 55~~
~~^".gcode""" appends the string .gcode"~~

~~Leaves you with~~
~~M98 P"randomnumber.gcode"~~

I was wrong,
After some testing it seems here's the syntax.

M98 P{random(55)}^".gcode"

dc42

@ironhydroxide the correct syntax is:

M98 P{random(55)^".gcode"}

ironhydroxide

@dc42 Thanks for that correction.

Tested with my system and it seemed to work the other way (though likely can cause problems when getting more complex)

mrehorstdmd

@dc42 I have drawing files in /gcodes/draw/ and wipe files in /gcodes/wipe/ folders. All files are renamed with numeric names and gcode extension, like "16.gcode".

I have tried about 50 variations on:

M98 P{/gcodes/draw/random(214)^".gcode"}
and get various error messages, mostly about expecting a string at one column or another.

How do I specify the folder to find the target files? Is this syntax documented somewhere?

Thanks!

m98 P"/gcodes/draw/^{random(22)}^.gcode"
Warning: Macro file /gcodes/draw/^{random(22)}^.gcode not found
ok
M98 P"/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file /gcodes/draw/{random(55)^ not found
Error: Bad command: gcode"}
ok
M98 P{/gcodes/draw/{andom(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 7: M98: expected an expression
ok
M98 P{/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 7: M98: expected an expression
ok
M98 P{/gcodes/draw/random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 7: M98: expected an expression
ok
M98 P "/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcode"}
ok
M98 P "/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^.gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
ok
M98 P {/gcodes/draw/random(55)^.gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
ok
M98 P{random(55)^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file 39.gcode not found
ok
M98 P /gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
ok
M98 P "/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}"
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcode"}"
ok
M98 P "/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcode"
ok
M98 P "/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcode"}
ok
M98 P /gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}
ok
M98 P "/gcodes/draw/{random(55)^".gcode"}"
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcode"}"
ok
M98 P "/gcodes/draw/"^{random(55)^".gcode"}"
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
ok
M98 P /gcodes/draw/^{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
Error: Bad command: gcodes/draw/^{random(55)^".gcode"}
ok
M98 P {/gcodes/draw/random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
ok
M98 P {0:/gcodes/draw/random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
ok
M98 P "0:/gcodes/draw/"^{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
ok
M98 P "0:/gcodes/draw/"{random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 6: M98: expected a string expression
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/"{random(55)^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/ not found
ok
M98 P{0:/gcodes/draw/random(55)^".gcode"}
Error:  at column 8: M98: expected '}'
ok
M98 P"{0:/gcodes/draw/random(55)"^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file {0:/gcodes/draw/random(55) not found
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/{random(55)"^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/{random(55) not found
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/{random(55)}"^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/{random(55)} not found
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/{random(55)}"^".gcode"
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/{random(55)} not found
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/"{random(55)}"^".gcode"
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/ not found
Error: Bad command: gcode"
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/"^{random(55)}"^".gcode"
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/ not found
Error: Bad command: gcode"
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/"^{random(55)}^".gcode"
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/ not found
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/"^{random(55)^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/ not found
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/"^"{random(55)^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/ not found
Error: Bad command: gcode"}
ok
M98 P"0:/gcodes/draw/^"{random(55)^".gcode"}
Warning: Macro file 0:/gcodes/draw/^ not found
ok

dc42

@mrehorstdmd try this:

M98 P{"/gcodes/draw/"^random(214)^".gcode"}

mrehorstdmd

@dc42 That's it! Thanks!

o_lampe

The Slim Delta is alive and I could reach areas outside of the triangle.
The problem is, how do I tell RRF that it mustn't foul the towers?
I know there are people using that for their leadscrew area and such, but I couldn't find it in the Wiki.

o_lampe

Just found out that M599 can define keep out zones. But searching for "keep out" in the Wiki gave no result...
Bad news is, it only works on Duet3 boards due to RAM restrictions.

Guess I can build a few sandify patterns, that match such an odd working area, but wipe-patterns usually apply to rectangular or polar areas only

droftarts

@o_lampe said in Spirograph emulator with Duet2:

The problem is, how do I tell RRF that it mustn't foul the towers?

As far as I'm aware there's no way for the firmware to do that. I guess you need to control that when slicing. I'd say it was rare to design a machine with the axes inside the build area.

@o_lampe said in Spirograph emulator with Duet2:

Just found out that M599 can define keep out zones.

Currently only one keep out zone is supported, and the job will be aborted with an error message if the toolhead tries to move inside that zone.

Ian

o_lampe

@droftarts said in Spirograph emulator with Duet2:

I'd say it was rare to design a machine with the axes inside the build area.

You're right, but I wanted the footprint of the table aka delta tower-triangle to be small.

I got a nice 38cm dia glasstable with a predrilled footprint of 320mm. I'll have to place the towers accordingly.

@droftarts said in Spirograph emulator with Duet2:

Currently only one keep out zone is supported

Guess, I have to write a postprocessor which takes care of three keepout zones and doesn't quit the job.

mrehorstdmd

@o_lampe What do you plan to use to generate the drawing and erase pattern files? Maybe the keepout areas can be defined there.

You can do all sorts of stuff with post processors. I use a PERL post processor to set the speed of moves on my table. It steps through the pattern file and determines whether each line of gcode draws on the table or moves the ball along the edges. If it's edge motion, it executes it at high speed (usually 1000 mm/sec), and if it's drawing on the table it executes at a lower speed (to preserve detail in the drawing).

o_lampe

@mrehorstdmd Currently I'm using Sandify, but I can also produce gcode from .dxf files. With inkscape I could theoreticaly use any bitmap to generate patterns and I could manually drag every knot of a path out of the zones.
I used it frequently, when my K40 laser was new.

I haven't thought to look elsewhere, but if others (CNC or laser scene? ) have the same problem with keep out zones, I'd be happy to know.
Is the PERL post processor open source? I'm looking for a good starting point to write my own.(open file, modify gcode lines, write new file)

mrehorstdmd

@o_lampe Here's my PERL script for dual speed operation. I used a LOT of notes to make it easy for me to modify or fix because I don't do a lot of programming and have to relearn it for each project.

This is how it is invoked:

E:\Downloads>perl -w dual_speedify_v2.pl

Warning- there's no error trapping, so be careful when you answer
the questions that will follow. Use at your own risk!

Type the name of the sandify pattern file:
250519_01.gcode
Enter the drawing speed in mm/sec
150
Enter the edge speed in mm/sec
1000
Enter the minimum X value of the pattern.
0
Enter the maximum X value of the pattern.
590
Enter the minimum Y value of the pattern.
0
Enter the maximum Y value of the pattern.
980
Enter the home position X ordinate.
590
Enter the home position Y ordinate.
0

Processing is complete.

The dual speed output file is called 250519_01_9000_60000.gcode

Check the output file to make sure it does what you think it will.

And the attached file is the result. 250519_01_9000_60000.gcode ]

o_lampe

@o_lampe said in Spirograph emulator with Duet2:

A SCARA arm in the center would be nice, but I don't know if RRF supports the 360° working area? @dc42 @JoergS5 ?

Just wanted to bump up the question, because it would be the most hidden mechanic.

When I run the delta driven sand table, people spend more time watching the effector and trying to figure out how it works.

dc42

@o_lampe the current Scara implementation assumes that both the proximal and distal arms move through a limited range of angles; whereas I think the design you are looking at supports continuous rotation. So I think the answer is no.