How reliable is the IR bed sensor Vs BLTouch?

57buick

I've been using bltouch for awhile and they work fine. I am curious if its worth switching to the new IR Duet bed sensor? How reliable are they gonna be in comparison?

Veti

have you seen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=il9bNWn66BY

measure your sd with this https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/6962/m48-measure-z-probe-repeatability-and-print-to-serial-output

oliof

A rough comparison is on the wiki: https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/Choosing_a_Z_probe

CaLviNx

I have a single genuine Bltouch, while it worked (most of the time with lots of messing about) I just never liked the levelling results it gave, so I took it out, I have 6 IR sensors on my home Cartesian printers and a smart effector on my delta, I also fitted 11 IR sensors to our work machines, to me the IR sensor is almost fit and forget once it has been set up.

T3P3Tony

@57buick it very much depends on your bed surface. What surface do you use?

57buick

well I've been experimenting on lots of different materials trying to decide what I like best. I like printing on glass and mirrors though

flipil

Okey then you should forget the IR Sensor. It's crazy accurate, but not in combination with mirrors or glass. I almost lost my mind with the IR-Sensor, because of the wrong surface I used.(Dont get me wrong: I LOVE the IR Sensor NOW, but it can be a little bi**h on certain surfaces)

zapta

@flipil said in How reliable is the IR bed sensor Vs BLTouch?:

It's crazy accurate, but not in combination with mirrors or glass..

How about PEI? E.g. this one https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B074XG1NDM attached to flexible steel plate?

hussainsail2002

I have been working with bl touch sensors for quite a while now and am quite un-happy them, when they work they work fine. The problem is 1 in every 5 probing cycles fail. I need to restart the machine a few times before getting the probing to work accurately again. I have bought 10 bl touch sensors out of which around 6 have this problem. I was using these on the MKS gen 1.4

Looking for new bed leveling sensors, definitely interested if someone can give a comparison or review of the ir sensor

Veti

@hussainsail2002

have a look at this. its a bltouch replacement, but i found it to be even more accurate and its not prone to interference.

https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3303618

CaLviNx

@flipil

we print on glass with an IR sensor, our simple fix was to put a layer of cheap matt black vinyl on the underside of the glass, viola no issues with the IR sensor not triggering...

DocTrucker

I like the dc42 IR probe but I am having problems with it on a hair sprayed glass even with a sheet of black paper under the glass. I believe it is good with a clean glass plate with matt black backing.

If you have a look at the last graph on the following link you can see that it's standard deviation is tight. I'm not ruling out another mechanical issue for the thicker layer near the front of the bed vs the back.

https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/11483/probe-drift-dc42-ir-inductive-heat-no-heat/17

P3Steels nearly running again so should be able to do a far better comparison soon.

deckingman

I use 3dLac on my glass because I can lay down the first layer at the same speed I print at (generally 60 - 90mm/sec) and because when the glass cools, parts just fall off (but sometimes need a tap). But that plays havoc with DC's IR probe so I'd imagine that hair spray would have a similar effect.

DocTrucker

@deckingman is there indication that 3DLac is anything other than branded hairspray?

Edit: Genuine enquiry, not trying to be provocative.

deckingman

@doctrucker said in How reliable is the IR bed sensor Vs BLTouch?:

@deckingman is there indication that 3DLac is anything other than branded hairspray?

Edit: Genuine enquiry, not trying to be provocative.

Only the sales blurb Quote " The Original and Unique spray adhesive created to use with 3D printers". That and the fact that it's fragrance free. But it could be hair spray without fragrance - who knows?

TBH, I've never done a back to back comparison because my wife doesn't use hair spray (and I don't have enough hair to warrant it either ) .

If hair spray works for you and you can get it cheaper than 3D Lac, then stick with it (pun intended ).

CaLviNx

@deckingman

Due to the stupid restrictions of not being able to send aerosols via Air (I live on the island of cyprus so everything is normally flown in) I can't buy 3dlac...

So I use printafix (basically hairspray in a pump bottle) and it doesn't appear to mess with the IR Sensor.

bearer

Odds are its polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) which is the main ingredient in most hairsprays, but its probably also lacking some of the hair specific stuff like fragrance.

I'd love to do a test, but also suffer from shipping restrictions, and while I'm a huge fan of empirical data I don't think getting married for science is something I'm likely to do, but lets find out...:D

deckingman

@calvinx said in How reliable is the IR bed sensor Vs BLTouch?:

@deckingman

Due to the stupid restrictions of not being able to send aerosols via Air (I live on the island of cyprus so everything is normally flown in) I can't buy 3dlac...

So I use printafix (basically hairspray in a pump bottle) and it doesn't appear to mess with the IR Sensor.

Fair enough. For info, you can get 3D lac in 100mm pump action sprays but it's s**t expensive. A 400mm pressurised spray is about £10 if you shop around but a 100mm pump action is about £7.00, so nearly 3 times the price per unit volume.

Edit - Strewth! I just checked the price for "PrintaFix here in the UK and it's £12 to £15 for 100mm and £55 for 500ml. So it might be worth seeing if you can get 3DLac in 100ml pump action shipped to Cyprus. On the other hand, it does play havoc with the IR sensor so maybe not.

droftarts

On the Ultimaker 2+ at my old work, I used a sugar solution for bed adhesion: https://hackaday.com/2019/01/05/sugar-as-a-bed-adhesive-for-3d-printing/
It's a bit of a hassle to put on (need to do 3 layers, let it dry out in between, but doesn't take long if bed is heated), but sticks PLA and ABS beautifully (didn't try PETG), and can do a number of prints before having to be redone. Cheap too! You can mix up a larger amount and put it in a spray bottle too. Don't know how it would work with IR probe though, assume similar to hairspray. If I ever get my Cartesian printer back up and running with IR probe, I'll try it out.

Ian

dc42

I suggest not using the IR probe if you use any sort of coating on the glass. It works fine on uncoated glass (except mirror) if there is a uniform matt surface underneath - preferably matt black. And most brands of PLA print well on uncoated glass, if you prepare the glass correctly before you fir it to the bed plate.