Same .gcode file - two different printers - very different results
-
Some questions for you:
1. Is the model half the size it should be in all 3 of X, Y and Z?
2. Are you using 1.8 or 0.9deg motors?
3. Do the X, Y and Z jog buttons in Duet Web Control move the print head by the amounts you ask for?
-
1- Only the Z axis appears different, X and Y look fine ..
2. 1.8 deg steppers on X.Y. Z .. (Extruder is titan w/ 0.9)
3. The jog buttons (the +/- X.Y.Z buttons?) .. I am not sure what you are asking here… They all move and in the right direction.. but I don't know whether they move the proper amount or not.. is that what you are asking? Sorry .. How do I ascertain that? -
https://photos.google.com/photo/AF1QipOlWXhrREuVYjKKfoCeHcI0rezTTRutaCMDOtgl
https://photos.google.com/photo/AF1QipNZ7kfGQyRioLUL7DPl8z_519Mvj0YaE8px4VjGSorry, photos not perfectly clear but they do show that the Z is different
-
Is this the titan causing this wit the 0.9 motor?
-
3. The jog buttons (the +/- X.Y.Z buttons?) .. I am not sure what you are asking here… They all move and in the right direction.. but I don't know whether they move the proper amount or not.. is that what you are asking? Sorry .. How do I ascertain that?
you can measure this using a ruler.
Move the Z-axis for example 100mm and verify if it really moved 100mm.
To me it seems your Z-axis steps are high, but it depends on the leadscrews you are using… -
How is your Z Driven ie is it a screw if so what size screw is it also on your Ramps setup could you have had 1/8 microstepping set on the Z axis?
Doug
-
3. The jog buttons (the +/- X.Y.Z buttons?) .. I am not sure what you are asking here… They all move and in the right direction.. but I don't know whether they move the proper amount or not.. is that what you are asking? Sorry .. How do I ascertain that?
you can measure this using a ruler.
Move the Z-axis for example 100mm and verify if it really moved 100mm.
To me it seems your Z-axis steps are high, but it depends on the leadscrews you are using…2560 for Z would be correct for a 1.8 stepper driving the Z by a M5x0.8mm threaded rod assuming 1/16 microstepping
-
Z is screw driven .. no, there was no microsteppting on the Z under Ramps.. but there was some changes to the stepping for the extruder..
This is from the titan docs:
"
Usage
Firmware Calibration
Because Titan uses a known gearing ratio and a consistently machined drive gear, we can offer a fairly accurate steps / mm set-point. Forgot about that ..Steps per Unit (Extruder) = Motor Steps * Micro-stepping * Gear Ratio / (Hobb Diameter * Pi)
Standard motor steps / rev = 400 for the new style motor or 200 for the old style motor (Refer to assembly steps if unsure which motor you have).
Standard micro-stepping = 16x
Gear Ratio = 3
Hobb Diameter (Effective) = 7.3
200 * 16 * 3 / (7.3 * 3.142) = 418.5
400 * 16 * 3 / (7.3 * 3.142) = 837 "I changed that number under ramps .. Is there something similar under the RepRap configs?
-
There is this command in the config:
M92 E420:420 ; Set extruder steps per mm
looks like this has to change. but is this causing the problem ..
will update it to:
M92 E840:840 ; Set extruder steps per mm
does this seem reasonable?
Why not, giving it a try ..
-
No that will not affect your Z AXis hight at all?
-
Probably not, but sounds like it needs to be done anyway??
-
Looks like no difference .. when done printing will try to measure the "jog" on the Z axis ..
-
What is the thread pitch on your Z axis screw? is there any gearing between the Z axis motor and the screw?
Alternatively, do you know what Z steps/mm you were using in the firmware for the other board?
-
Tried a jog of +100 and measured 65 mm change.. Will repeat .. Pretty much same result ..
Could this be a current problem to the Z steppers (2) -
Looking to find your answers .. Have to find the old marlin code .. and of course it is not on this computer .. will be back when I have the answers .. I believe the P3 came with M5x295 screw rods if that helps ..
-
It could be that your Z steps/mm are wrong, or your X acceleration is too high, or your Z maximum speed is too high, or the Z motor current is too low. You should be able to get all of these details except the motor current from your Marlin config file.
One other possibility: if you have two Z motors and they are badly-chosen high inductance low current types, then the series connection used by the two Z motors connectors on the Duet won't work well with them, and you will need to connect them in parallel instead. Can you read the model number of the Z motors from the label?
-
Some numbers :
Steppers SL42STH40-1684A
MARLIN:
DefaultAxisStepsPerUnit 80,80,4000, 775 – the 4000 looks bigger than the config val
Default Acceleration 3000
-
Yup z Steps are set to 2560 .. try a change to 4000?
Ratios look about right for measurements ..
warmin up for a test print .. -
If you got a 65mm change when commanding 100, then 4000 will get you close.
-
BTW, your pictures in this post and another you posted in, are not working.