Hollow shaft extruder

droftarts

@droftarts I'm not happy with the dual drive gears somewhere in the middle of the assembly. They should be lowest as possible (e.g. for flexible filament). That's why I didn't increase the blue bevel gears in my sketch.

Good point. A smaller second gear would bring it closer, at the expense of gear ratio.

The ingenius extruder is quite impressive, but top heavy IMHO. ... Those square NEMA14 motors are so heavy compared to the round ones, I'm surprised, he picked one of these...

Yes, that was my initial thought, too.

A two stage gearing would make it more compact, I guess.

But more backlash/complexity/cost?

The hypoid drive reminded me a bit of a worm drive, which might be an option, too?

It's kind of a cross between a spiral bevel gear and a worm drive. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiral_bevel_gear#Hypoid_gears
The advantage is that it can transmit more torque than a spiral bevel gear, but, like a worm drive, they also have some sliding action along the teeth.

Which CAD system can calculate them? (hypoid)

This is about the only CAD tutorial I could find for making hypoid gears, though uses Blender, I'm sure it could be done in Fusion 360 or OpenSCAD: https://youtu.be/wWn9gYwnONk
There's a calculator here http://www.otvinta.com/hypoid.html (they also have calculators and videos for other gears

Also, if it helps your design, Orbiter v2.0 uses shorter drive gears; 11mm vs 15mm. You could reduce the size of the motor gear, then.

Ian

nikscha

@droftarts Way ahead of you

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eI0tD69wD18

droftarts

@nikscha I saw... I give up! Yours is very nice, I like how you're trying to squeeze the filament sensor in there too. How did you model the hypoid gear? I saw from your videos you're using Fusion 360.

Ian

nikscha

@o_lampe said in Hollow shaft extruder:

@droftarts I'm not happy with the dual drive gears somewhere in the middle of the assembly. They should be lowest as possible (e.g. for flexible filament)
That's why I didn't increase the blue bevel gears in my sketch.

The ingenius extruder is quite impressive, but top heavy IMHO.
A two stage gearing would make it more compact, I guess.
Those square NEMA14 motors are so heavy compared to the round ones, I'm surprised, he picked one of these...

The hypoid drive reminded me a bit of a worm drive, which might be an option, too?
Which CAD system can calculate them? (hypoid)

*Ingenuity Extruder

I actually ordered a round one from LDO, and torque per weight seemed to be much better for the square one. Obviously this is only in the prototype stage (I am actually looking for beta testers right now), and any help with the motor design would be appreciated!

I used a blender tutorial to model the hypoid bevel gears. Rest is done in fusion. But there are also proper calculators (MIT calculator) for hypoid bevel gears.

nikscha

@droftarts I followed a blender tutorial hahaha. The math is done here for you: http://www.otvinta.com/hypoid.html

I want to open source this design under Creative Commons, so any help is appreciated!

I'm actually looking for beta testers, and maybe we can make this a kit!

nikscha

Damn I wanted to wait a bit longer with posting about the Ingenuity extruder on the forum but I guess it's too late now

It's a direct drive extruder which features a hollow-shaft Nema-14 stepper motor, Bondtech LGX drive gear, an eccentric breach which is self-locking, an idler wheel where the spokes act as a tensioning spring and a hypoid bevel gear pair, archiving a gear ratio of 37:7.

The whole mechanism features only 4 moving parts: two gears, the idler wheel and the breach-lever. Weight is 229g.

https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:6056191

droftarts

@nikscha Do you think there's any way you can reduce the diameter of the large gear? My first impression was that it would be a bit top heavy, though a lighter motor would help with that. @o_lampe 's point about it being a long way from the drive gear to the hot end, particularly for flexible filaments, could also be problematic.

What is your view on the Archimedes screw extruder?

Ian

nikscha

Sorry for highjacking this post by the way, I made a separate one here:
https://forum.duet3d.com/topic/32876/ingenuity-extruder-for-smart-effector

droftarts

@nikscha said in Hollow shaft extruder:

Sorry for highjacking this post by the way

No worries, after all your extruder is a hollow shaft extruder, and that's what this thread is about!

Ian

nikscha

@droftarts said in Hollow shaft extruder:

@nikscha Do you think there's any way you can reduce the diameter of the large gear? My first impression was that it would be a bit top heavy, though a lighter motor would help with that. @o_lampe 's point about it being a long way from the drive gear to the hot end, particularly for flexible filaments, could also be problematic.

What is your view on the Archimedes screw extruder?

Ian

Well the diameter of the "wheel" depends on multiple factors, like hypoid offset, gear ratio and number of teeth.
The hypoid offset is limited by the diameter of the drive wheel, which is the bondtech LGX in my case. gear ratio is aimed at 1:7, and tooth size is limited by the material properties.
I made all my prototypes from resin gears (Sirayatech white mecha), which were quite brittle, but I've since moved to gears made from IGUS SLS plastics. They're much stronger and more durable, and with them it might be possible to have a smaller wheel and/or a higher reduction ratio.

While testing I found that the "top heaviness" isn't that much of a problem, I'll post my input shaping results later for proof

.
.
.

About the Archimedes screw extruder:

Very neat! And so light! I am jealous!
But there's no way of tensioning the filament, and loading/unloading can only be done electronically.
A harder filament will also provide more resistance to deformation which might stall the extruder. A softer filament might slip. There's also only one "teeth" engaging with the filament, so it might slip easier, especially considering that there's no way of tensioning it.
Abrasive filament will also dull the knife edge.

Edit:
A quick calculation shows that at 15degree pitch one revolution of the screw will advance the filament by about 1.5mm (tan15 * 1.75 *pi), the archimedes extruder has (360/1.8)= 200 steps per revolution, so about 133.33 steps per mm, which is not that much.

Edit2: judging from this: https://youtu.be/YTADdWiFQnI?t=238 my math is wrong, and the archimedes extruder needs about two revolutions to advance the filament by 1.75mm, which implies 1.14 revolutions for 1mm. This is equal to 228 steps/mm

o_lampe

@nikscha Thanks for joining the conversation.
I've made some small gears with ABS-like resin and also Anycubics tough resin.
Especially the latter is promising for testing gears. Could you achieve the same ratio with a smaller module? Your hypoid wheel looks like it can lift a car...but there is not much torque to deal with.

nikscha

@o_lampe
I don't think resin gears are the way forward. You want something abrasion resistant because hypoid bevel gears slightly rub against each other, it's not a pure rolling motion like spur gears for example.
Instead I'm using SLS printed gears (IGUS).

One BIG problem that needs solving is the stepper getting hot. Usually this isn't a problem, but with a hollow shaft extruder the filament going through the shaft will get hot. Pla especially will soften quickly. Resin printed pinions that sit on the shaft will soften as well.
I had to run my old stepper at 600mA, while it's rated at 800, just to prevent overheating. I remedy this by counterboring the shaft from the top, and inserting a thin-walled ptfe tube for insulation.
The new stepper that has the ptfe tube and Igus gears can run hotter (obviously), but I haven't tested it enough yet.

If you have a delta printer and a smart effector and want to help me test, please hit me up, I'll gladly sent you a gear pair and custom stepper motor.

nikscha

@o_lampe

You definitely could archive the same ratio with a smaller module.
Don't overestimate the hypoid gears tho, the ratio is only about 1:7, and the stepper is a nema 14, so not much torque here either.

I should also state again that the diameter of the bigger gear is a function of hypoid shift. Hypoid shift is among other determined by the diameter of the drive wheel, in my case an LGX hardened drive wheel by bondtech. You could use a smaller one, maybe something that's used in the orbiter which is using 12mm diameter drive wheels instead of the LGX 18mm, which makes the hypoid shift 6mm instead of 9mm.

But this now means that the pinion is so small that you can't have it sit on a stepper motor shaft, it's diameter is now only 4mm instead of the 5.7mm I get with the LGX gears. This means that the red section will be too thin:

OwenD

Interesting concept.
I'll be interested to see if the resonant frequencies common in hypoid gears have an effect on extrusion.

nikscha

@OwenD Could you elaborate? I haven't heard of those resonant frequencies

OwenD

@nikscha said in Hollow shaft extruder:

@OwenD Could you elaborate? I haven't heard of those resonant frequencies

My experience with regards to printing has only been with the Zesty nimble.
If you search you should find plenty of examples of the artifacts.
The V2 version is supposed to have fixed this, but I'd given up by then.
Hence my interest to see if this implementation of similar gears will present with the same issues.

The older of us would be well familiar with these frequencies on car differentials.
There is plenty of research on how these frequencies occur, but the math is well over my head.

nikscha

@OwenD

I printed @MIHAIDESIGNS extruder test piece and it looks very smooth.
Does that answer your question?

OwenD

@nikscha said in Hollow shaft extruder:

@OwenD

I printed @MIHAIDESIGNS extruder test piece and it looks very smooth.
Does that answer your question?

I don't see the same patterns, but there does seem to be some irregular extrusion in places.
It probably looks worse in the photo than in person and is way less than the issue I had.
Not trying to hose down the idea, just interested from a mechanics point of view.

nikscha

@OwenD

You're right, they're not perfect. But close
I used to use the Flex3Drive and the Ingenuity extruder is quite a bit more consistent.

MirageC made some interesting conclusions in this video, which I tried to consider in my design.
The alignment of the gears is constrained by the LGX drive gear and a roller bearing, and the idler is basically flat, so there shouldn't be any lateral forces on the filament:

o_lampe

@nikscha said in Hollow shaft extruder:

I don't think resin gears are the way forward.

It's perfect for testing and the ABS-like resin withstands 200°C+ , way more than the stepper temp will raise.
It's also a good starting point if you want to cast a silicone mould and reproduce it in bigger quantities.
Although the abrasion of an hypoid gear is an issue without lube or grease. Did you try that?