Oddly shaped holes?
-
@Surgikill said in Oddly shaped holes?:
LM16UU
I think you’re on the right path regarding the igus bushings causing the oddly shaped circles. I bought into the hype of the polymer bushings but had print quality issues. In my case the sticktion could be felt when manually moving the axis with the belts removed. Either they were loose to prevent sticktion and had excessive play or they were tight and caused the oddly shaped circles like you are experiencing. Also found that the rods need to be completely dry and cleaned regularly. Not worth it, went back to LM16UU bearings and the issue went away.
-
@mwolter Yup. I've had the same issues where they're either too loose or too tight. Hopefully the LM16UU fix that issue.
-
Those IGUS bushings have pretty tight tolerances on how they are supposed to be mounted. There is a lot to read on their website.
I have tried them a few times, but as many of you say they either bind or have play.
They seem to be popular in the industry, "lubricated by dirt". -
Igus has plastic bushings that are encapsulated in a hard shell. This way you can clamp it without increasing the binding on the rod. E.g.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00QZ7YJ7W
Linear bearings are available in double length but I couldn't find double length igus bushings and installing two one after the other creates non co-linearity that increases the binding.
-
@bondus Yes, the Igus bearings are built to quite tight tolerances, and to not like any mounting error or rod misalignment. Industrial equipment, which is what they are designed for, usually is toleranced more closely than 3d printers. I designed a bearing mount: https://github.com/mendenm/hemera_mount_plate which has a self-aligning lower bearing block which avoids this problem.
-
@zapta Yea I was looking at those but I wasn't going to pay 20-30 dollars a bushing when I need 8 of them. I'll just stick with the regular bearings. Are there any recommendations on good bearings? I have all chinesium ones right now, but if I find out that it does end up fixing my problem, I'll most likely upgrade to better bearings.
-
I used to use Thomson Super8 bearings when I was still using 1/2" round guide rails. I was buying them new on ebay for $5-8 each. They allow adjustment of preload and the races can tilt a little to compensate for slightly inaccurate mounting.
Make sure your rails are hardened- ball bearings will cut grooves into unhardened rails.
-
@mrehorstdmd @zapta @mendenmh @mwolter @arhi I just replaced the Igus bushings with the LM16UU I ordered. No more issues. Now I have no idea what to do with all these Igus bushings I have.
-
I'm a little late to the party I know but I started down the carbon fiber/igus route back in 2017 and although it "worked" it was way too finicky. The plain igus bearings MUST be press fit into a very specific hole diameter to be usable with the specified diameter diameter rods. Most of the carbon fiber rods I bought needed tuning with 1000-1500-2000 grit sandpaper to get them to have constant and reasonable friction in the bearings. Some could never be tuned properly because they were too narrow to begin with. Also, while most of the roll-wrapped ones were spot on for straightness, some were not which made trying to get matched sets almost impossible. In the end, I gave up.
-
@Surgikill said in Oddly shaped holes?:
Are there any recommendations on good bearings?
When I need good quality bearings and rods I get them from Misumi. They have a large selection and they sell them also in small quantities, including but to length rods.
-
@gtj0 said in Oddly shaped holes?:
I'm a little late to the party I know but I started down the carbon fiber/igus route back in 2017
The lure of light weight moving mass.
I tried bowden, igus bushings and carbon and aluminum rods but after a lot of trial and error realized that a solid design with stainless steal rods, real ball bearings and a direct drive give me the best print quality.
Time to adopt this term from the bicycling world
https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=weight weenie
-
@Surgikill said in Oddly shaped holes?:
Now I have no idea what to do with all these Igus bushings I have.
ebay?
-
@zapta You're correct of course but you can always learn something new by trying something no matter how it turns out.
-
@gtj0 But many others have tried before with the same results.
How many times does a known failure have to be duplicated? It's one thing if you think you understand why something failed and have some new twist to apply that you think is going to fix the problem, but something else entirely to simply copy other failures and expect that it will magically work this time.
Of course, you don't always know that something is a failure. A lot of people post their designs on the web, but not many of them post their failures. Sometimes you have to read between the lines to recognize a problem that the designer doesn't realize or won't admit exists. Also, the web never forgets. Maybe you post a bad design, then learn later that it's a problem, but that bad design is still out there. It can be a lot of trouble to try to update or expunge old posts, especially if there are a lot of them.
-
@mrehorstdmd Yeah isn't the definition of insanity "doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result"?
Still, as I've said in other posts, I learned a great deal in that exercise and would not trade it for anything. Some day someone will do something that "has been done 1000 times before" and discover something new. -
@gtj0 If you can gain the knowledge by reading, watching a youtube video, or even just thinking a problem through, is it worthwhile to spend time and money testing the failure yourself? The whole point of people bothering to publish their results is to show others how something can be done or to show how something doesn't work so others don't have to duplicate the same errors/failure. That's the way progress is made. If everyone had to reinvent the wheel every time they needed a wheel, we'd still be living in caves.
"Some day someone will do something that "has been done 1000 times before" and discover something new."
No, they won't. Not if they do it the same way those 1000 other people did it. No one who knows what a hammer is has to hit their thumb with it to know it's going to hurt. You can try 1000...00 times and it's going to hurt every time. -
But many others have tried before with the same results.
hm, I have igus on my M150 and it works flawlesly. not only it is silent I got rid of all the ringing I had with linear bearings fore that .. I changed to igus 'cause I seen some superb results from other ppl so I would not agree that it's a given that igus will bring you problem
-
@mrehorstdmd said in Oddly shaped holes?:
is it worthwhile to spend time and money testing the failure yourself?
Sometimes! I find the spark of creativity only comes when you're bashing your head against a problem with your own bare hands. Reading about it just doesn't generate the brain activity needed.
-
@arhi I have no doubt that they can be made to work, especially if you follow the manufacturer's recommended methods of using them, which few people building 3D printers do.
-
@mrehorstdmd The dozen or so patents I have are all for stuff others tried and found impossible to do.
@Phaedrux +1
