Smart Effector issue

Phaedrux

Interesting. I wonder if it's a sensitivity problem then.

I assume it's been disassembled and reassembled already?

tecno

Still as in latest picture = no duct.
Total weight is 84grams with 3 fans, printed in PETG.

jay_s_uk

@phaedrux that duct design (which is mine) works fine for me on my smart effector v3 so i doubt thats the issue. I still think its a mechanical issue with effector tilt

tecno

Have found my main issue = the printed effector adapter is way too small = too short rods.

Back to the drawing board!

tecno

A bit larger adapter

tecno

One violent move and this is the result.

tecno

So some days has gone and I am now trying to get the Smart Effector to work = no go!

New non 3D printed effector adapter (original in alu with slight modifications)

Area of bed 9 to 3 down to 6 can be probed G30 and 0,0 towards back about 50mm works
Out of that area the smart effector is not sensitive enough as the effector needs to tilt a lot before it triggers.
I find this a bit odd as the trigger LED on head moves. All set to default values.

bed.g

config.g

Phaedrux

Your dive speed seems to be half the recommended value. M558 F600 vs M558 F1200

https://docs.duet3d.com/en/Duet3D_hardware/Accessories/Smart_Effector#configuring-firmware

M558 P8 R0.8 C"probe+servo0" H10 F600 T2000

M558 P8 R0.4 F1200

So perhaps it's not striking with enough force to reliably trigger.

tecno

@phaedrux

And looks like that, had to go all way up to 2500 to get reliable trig.

Where do I set hotend offset and where to set effector offset?
Looking from front X0/Y0 effector is to left and the hotend is a bit left too.

Phaedrux

@tecno said in Smart Effector issue:

Where do I set hotend offset and where to set effector offset?
Looking from front X0/Y0 effector is to left and the hotend is a bit left too.

I'm not sure what you mean.

dc42

FWIW we've identified a modification to the Smart Effector version 3 that improves the signal-to-noise ratio, which in turn allows you to use a higher sensitivity unless fan noise etc. prevents that. The modification is to remove capacitor C8. This can be done using a soldering iron with a bit large enough to cover both pads. Alternatively, you could use a small twist drill bit to remove a thin sliver of copper around the adjacent via that connects one end of the capacitor to the ground plane.

This image is as viewed from the top of the PCB, so you need to invert it when looking at the bottom.

tecno

@phaedrux said in Smart Effector issue:

@tecno said in Smart Effector issue:

Where do I set hotend offset and where to set effector offset?
Looking from front X0/Y0 effector is to left and the hotend is a bit left too.

I'm not sure what you mean.

; Tools
M563 P0 D0 H1 F0 ; define tool 0
G10 P0 X-4 Y0 Z0 ; set tool 0 axis offsets
G10 P0 R0 S0

Fixed offset issue

tecno

@dc42 said in Smart Effector issue:

FWIW we've identified a modification to the Smart Effector version 3 that improves the signal-to-noise ratio, which in turn allows you to use a higher sensitivity unless fan noise etc. prevents that. The modification is to remove capacitor C8. This can be done using a soldering iron with a bit large enough to cover both pads. Alternatively, you could use a small twist drill bit to remove a thin sliver of copper around the adjacent via that connects one end of the capacitor to the ground plane.

This image is as viewed from the top of the PCB, so you need to invert it when looking at the bottom.

So far during my tests no fans are used, good to know when adding fans.

tecno

Still some issues with false trig = does not go down but LED lights up = trig.

How to solve this?

Phaedrux

When and where was it purchased?

tecno

Warning: Skipping grid point X=40.0, Y=60.0 because Z probe cannot reach it
37 points probed, min error -0.260, max error 0.240, mean -0.026, deviation 0.113
Height map saved to file 0:/sys/heightmap.csv

From where does this X=40.0, Y=60.0 coordinate originate?

tecno

@phaedrux said in Smart Effector issue:

When and where was it purchased?

A few weeks ago via James

tecno

@tecno said in Smart Effector issue:

@phaedrux

And looks like that, had to go all way up to 2500 to get reliable trig.

Where do I set hotend offset and where to set effector offset?
Looking from front X0/Y0 effector is to left and the hotend is a bit left too.

Now on 3500 and the false trigs seems to be away, but need more testing to be sure.
Also Dive height affects this now on 5mm

dc42

@tecno have you tried the following to eliminate the false triggering:

increase the R parameter in the M558 command, in case it is the previous XY move causing the spurious triggering;
reduce the probing acceleration, because it may be the Z acceleration at the start of the probing move that causes the spurious triggering.

tecno

@dc42 said in Smart Effector issue:

@tecno have you tried the following to eliminate the false triggering:

increase the R parameter in the M558 command, in case it is the previous XY move causing the spurious triggering;

reduce the probing acceleration, because it may be the Z acceleration at the start of the probing move that causes the spurious triggering.

Tried R0.8 still the issue +++ Will not go down to bed on all points !!!