Another Predator

boldnuts

Based on the video it looks to me that your nozzle is still slightly to high and your printing your first layer to fast, your print moves also seem quite jerky. Have you lubricated the haydn magball ends as he recommends ? https://www.magballarms.com/

Carlo

Hi,

Yes they are well lubricated with a similar dry product which is Teflon based, The trigger height during the video was/is currently
0.05.
I will add slicer settings later once it completes a layer out of interest what trigger height do you suggest ?...as I've tried a few in 0.01 increments
I don't seem to get any false triggers during travel when probing but i'll disconnect the fan during a probe and post again.
I did a G29 S2, G28 then G32 prior to the print.
My bed has G29 S2 added to it and is currently Factor 6 I've tried Factor 8 no benefit/visible effect.

; bed.g file for RepRapFirmware, generated by Escher3D calculator
; 10 points, 6 factors, probing radius: 170, probe offset (0, 0)
G30 P0 X0.00 Y170.00 Z-99999 H0
G30 P1 X147.22 Y85.00 Z-99999 H0
G30 P2 X147.22 Y-85.00 Z-99999 H0
G30 P3 X0.00 Y-170.00 Z-99999 H0
G30 P4 X-147.22 Y-85.00 Z-99999 H0
G30 P5 X-147.22 Y85.00 Z-99999 H0
G30 P6 X0.00 Y85.00 Z-99999 H0
G30 P7 X73.61 Y-42.50 Z-99999 H0
G30 P8 X-73.61 Y-42.50 Z-99999 H0
G30 P9 X0 Y0 Z-99999 S6

G29 S2

I'll go and move the fan to another socket so I can control it add the M106 and try some more settings again.
So the height will make it complete the arcs which it doesn't at the moment.
So it's just 2 settings move the fan and find a new height .Oh and use the file sliced by another forum user cool...that second one may be a bit trickier now I'm thinking about it ! but hey once more in to the breach

As always big THANKS for the help it really is appreciated I know you don't have to help yet you do.

NexxCat

@Carlo
Try using this macro to configure your Z-probe offset. I wrote it and use it across multiple machines. Make sure to heat both the bed and nozzle. I use 60C on the bed and 130C on the nozzle:

;calibrate_z_probe_offset.g
G31 P100 X0 Y0 Z0			; Reset Z trigger height to 0mm
M290 R0 S0				; Reset babystepping
G29 S2					; Clear bed mesh
G28					; Home the effector
G1 X0 Y0 Z20 F6000			; Move close to the bed
G30					; Probe to find a rough Z 0mm

G1 X0 Y0 Z1 F3000			; Move the nozzle to Z 1mm slowly
G92 Z3.0				; Set the Z height to 3mm, allowing moves below 0
M291 P"Lower the nozzle to until it grips a piece of paper. Click to continue." S2 Z1
G92 Z0					; Define this point as 0mm
G1 X0 Y0 Z20				; Move the probe to Z 20mm
G30 S-3					; Probe and set the trigger height
G1 Z20					; Raise Z to 20mm

It will report your trigger height back, which you can then put into config.g

Carlo

@NexxCat

Thanks I'll try that right now.
Really appreciated.

Thanks C

Carlo

@NexxCat

Hi,

I ran the macro thanks for that results are:

1st
M98 P"0:/macros/Z probe report"
Z probe trigger height set to -0.084 mm

2nd
M98 P"0:/macros/Z probe report"
Z probe trigger height set to -0.146 mm

3rd
M98 P"0:/macros/Z probe report"
Z probe trigger height set to -0.159 mm

4th
M98 P"0:/macros/Z probe report"
Z probe trigger height set to -0.146 mm

5th
M98 P"0:/macros/Z probe report"
Z probe trigger height set to -0.159 mm

6th
M98 P"0:/macros/Z probe report"
Z probe trigger height set to -0.159 mm

So not sure what to set it to ... I know -0.159 I thought 3 out of 6 gotta be the one ....Its not the one.

after macro ztest.jpg

Thanks for the help oops guys or Ladies really appreciated PC correction

Phaedrux

I can't remember if this has been asked already, but has the bed been PID tuned?

Carlo

@Phaedrux

Hiya,

Yeah both H0/H1 have and they are in the config.
I'm calling it now..... I'm done off to research a replacement.

Really appreciate all the help from everyone big THANK YOU!

NexxCat

@Carlo
Did you use a single sheet of paper when it asked, just regular printer paper? Alternatively, if you have some feeler gauges, you can use a 0.10mm gauge.

droftarts

@Carlo From my earlier post: When you swapped the original board back in, did you also put the original effector back on, or did it use the smart effector? If you used the original effector (and presumably original probe), can you try that with the Duet? This would at least narrow down if it's the effector or the Duet.

Ian

Carlo

@NexxCat

Hi NexxCat

I used the back off a sticker which is 0.1mm on my calipers.
Just found my gauges !

Thanks

Carlo

@NexxCat

Hi,

So I used the well 0.102 feeler gauge though it is .10 with my calipers and 3 times got 3 heights.
I did video the whole process but that won't help me
The numbers don't actually help because they are not accurate though one of them is:

M98 P"0:/macros/Z probe report"
Z probe trigger height set to -0.159 mm

I don't think it's the effector because it does what it is supposed to do and no matter what trigger height I put in G31 line its the same outcome and the effector does return the same probe heights all be it not one after the other
maybe the drivers are not calculating correctly I don't know but it is what it is and that is not usable.

Cheers for your help.

C

NexxCat

@Carlo
Ok, last thing I can think of, just to double check if the actual positioning is being repeatable. Run these commands one at a time, or save it as a macro:

; Disable any baby-stepping and the bed mesh
M290 R0 S0
G29 S2

; Home the effector
G28

; Heat bed to 60C & nozzle to 130C
M104 S130 T0
M190 S60 T0
M109 S130 T0

; Run delta calibration
G32

; Move the effector to 0,0,Max height
G1 X0 Y0 F4500
G1 Z500 F4500

; Move the effector back to 10mm off the bed
G1 Z10 F4500

; Slowly move down to 0.1mm
G1 Z0.1 F600

When the macro is finished, the nozzle is at 0.1 on the Z axis. Use the paper or a 0.1mm feeler gauge and see if the nozzle truly is at 0.1mm

Carlo

@droftarts

Hi Ian,

I used the original effector with the mag arms (printed the adapters) whats funny is I didn't even try to get anything level or square I literally slapped it together set the offset 1 level and it just worked.
I have the effector still wired I can carefully attach it to the Duet2 and try it i cant fit the effector to the other board it's locked down
but I've written this thing off now I don't expect this to ever work with duet but after spending all this time I do want to know whats wrong maybe it will help someone else some day...probably not

I post a video of it once its fitted

Thanks
C

Carlo

@NexxCat

I'll do that now.

Cheers
C

Carlo

@NexxCat

Hi NexxCat,

No its 0.1mm to high

NexxCat

@Carlo
What is your current Z probe offset?

Carlo

@NexxCat

G31 P100 X0 Y0 Z-0.159

NexxCat

@Carlo
I can't remember offhand which way to adjust the offset to bring it closer, but try both of these, one will certainly be too high, but the other, does that give you a 0.1mm gap when running the macro I posted?

G31 P100 X0 Y0 Z-0.059

G31 P100 X0 Y0 Z-0.259

Carlo

@NexxCat

They have all been tried

it's 0.05 to bring it closer dc42 suggested 0.05 so I've tried all the -0. possible infact the video I posted is -0.05

NexxCat

@Carlo
I know you've tried them whilst printing, but try -0.059 and run the macro. Is the gap 0.1mm?